The city of Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss a wrongful-death lawsuit brought by Iryna Zarutska’s family, who allege security failures left her vulnerable aboard the city’s light-rail system. Charlotte argues that many of the decisions challenged in the case are protected by governmental immunity.
Zarutska’s killing attracted national attention after surveillance footage showed Decarlos Brown Jr. sitting behind her on a Lynx Blue Line train. About four minutes after she boarded, Brown is accused of stabbing her in the neck.
The 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee had just finished a shift at a local pizzeria.
Her family claims Charlotte failed to provide adequate policing and security throughout the light-rail system.
In a new court filing, the city argues that decisions involving transit policing, crime prevention, security contractors and public safety are governmental functions protected from liability under North Carolina law.
Charlotte’s filing also acknowledges that no private security guard was inside Zarutska’s train car when she was killed. It says Brown apparently boarded without displaying a ticket or pass and notes that the light-rail system does not use turnstiles or fare gates.
Zarutska’s family sued Charlotte and its private transit-security contractor, Professional Police Services, known as PPS, in August. The lawsuit alleges that security failures left passengers exposed to violent crime.
Charlotte responded Monday with a 34-page motion asking a Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge to dismiss the claims against the city.
The city says the lawsuit challenges “law-enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight, and public-safety administration.” Charlotte contends those activities fall under governmental immunity.
Zarutska’s family addressed that argument in its complaint, asserting that Charlotte waived immunity and that operating a fare-based light-rail system constitutes a proprietary, rather than governmental, function.
The complaint alleges that stricter fare enforcement, physical barriers and sufficient security might have stopped Brown from boarding the train or carrying out the attack.
It also cites findings by the North Carolina state auditor. According to those findings, Charlotte and the Charlotte Area Transit System, or CATS, planned to spend about $2.23 million on safety and security equipment in 2025 but spent approximately $470,000. About $1.76 million remained unspent, while some planned security work was left incomplete.
Charlotte denies neglecting passenger safety. The city says CATS had contracted armed and unarmed security personnel, worked with law enforcement and pursued other public-safety measures before Zarutska’s death.
The city further argues that Brown’s apparent failure to pay a fare did not indicate that he intended to attack Zarutska. It also says decisions involving security staffing, guard locations, surveillance and fare enforcement did not cause her death.
Charlotte maintains that Brown alone is responsible for Zarutska’s killing.
If the judge permits any claims against the city to proceed, Charlotte argues that Zarutska’s estate should not be allowed to recover more than $1 million.
The city is asking the judge to dismiss every claim against Charlotte and bar the family from refiling them. The judge has not yet ruled on the motion.
Fox News Digital contacted the City of Charlotte, Professional Police Services and an attorney representing Zarutska’s estate for comment on the motion to dismiss.
Fox News Digital’s Jasmine Baehr contributed to this report.