An Ohio woman convicted of suffocating her 5-year-old foster son and leaving his body in a sewer erupted at her sentencing hearing, directing a furious outburst at her own attorney.
“You are the Antichrist!” Pammy Maye shouted at lawyer Samuel Shamansky during the Nov. 19 hearing in Franklin County. “Yes, you are!”
Maye was found guilty of aggravated murder, tampering with evidence and gross abuse of a corpse in the death of Darnell Taylor, according to court records reviewed by Oxygen.
As deputies restrained her, Judge Mark Serrott urged Maye to cooperate. “You behaved well during the trial,” he said. “What you do today could affect your sentence.”
“No, I’m not going to stop,” the 51-year-old replied before deputies led her from the courtroom.
After Maye returned, Shamansky told the judge he would step away from the case because Maye no longer wanted him as her lawyer, Court TV reported.
“He represented me as if he were the prosecutor instead of defending me,” Maye said. “And everything shown in the footage about me was edited.”
Serrott, however, praised Shamansky’s performance, calling it “one of the best closing arguments I’ve ever seen with nothing really to work with.”
Maye then spoke indistinctly about “God’s wrath” and said she had been “possessed by demons” until Jesus visited her a month earlier.
The judge described Maye as “profoundly mentally ill” before sentencing her to 29 years to life in prison, with the possibility of parole.
Although she had caused a disruption earlier in the hearing, Maye wept while listening to statements from the victim’s family.
“I was very selfish,” she said, according to Court TV. “He was a loving child. He was a perfect child.”
The case began on Feb. 13, 2024, when prosecutor Katherine Wolfe said Maye became enraged after discovering Darnell had been hiding a granola bar and peanut butter crackers in his bed to eat later.
“It was at that time,” Wolfe said, “she decided she was going to take his life.”
The following night, Columbus police received a troubling call from Maye’s husband.
He said he had not seen Darnell throughout the day. Then, at roughly 3 a.m., Maye entered the bedroom, switched on the lights and told him that Darnell was dead.
According to a probable cause affidavit obtained by Oxygen, Maye allegedly placed her hand over her husband’s mouth during the 911 call and said she had a plan before leaving the house.
About two hours later, Maye’s silver Jeep Cherokee was discovered abandoned in suburban Cleveland, according to the Franklin County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office. She remained missing until the next evening, when she arrived at a business with plastic bags covering her feet.
After being taken to a hospital, Maye admitted that she had killed Darnell and directed investigators to his body.
Prosecutors said Maye confessed to suffocating the boy with a trash bag, securing it around his neck and placing him inside additional garbage bags. She then hid him in a living room closet.
She later put Darnell’s body in the rear of her Jeep, prosecutors said, moved him to the front during what she described as a “quick transaction” and ultimately left him in a sewer drain.
Maye told investigators the killing had been planned, again citing Darnell’s hidden bedtime snacks as the reason she decided to murder him.
Police recovered Darnell’s body from a Franklin Township sewer on Feb. 16.
At trial, Shamansky did not dispute that Maye killed Darnell. Instead, he argued that she should be found not guilty by reason of insanity.
“The woman who committed this unspeakable and horrible act was so consumed with mental illness, mental illnesses we can only begin to imagine,” he said, according to Court TV. “She was most certainly unable and ill-equipped to understand how wrong this act was, to appreciate the wrongfulness of her act.”
Prosecutors countered that, although Maye had a mental illness, it did not prevent her from understanding that her actions were wrong when she killed Darnell.
The jury reached its verdict in just three hours, convicting Maye on every count.