Chocolate heir Brad Reese has spoken publicly about living with end-stage cancer, revealing that his personal history is at the heart of his increasingly bitter dispute with Hershey.
The grandson of H.B. Reese, creator of the original peanut butter cup, told Our News Outlet that he has endured 16 brushes with death and spent years making frequent trips in and out of intensive care.
Reese also renewed his criticism of Hershey, accusing the company of damaging the flavor of products sold under the famous orange brand by replacing traditional ingredients with cheaper alternatives.
“They are killing the goose that is laying their golden eggs,” Reese told Our News Outlet.
He said his campaign against alleged recipe changes was driven by a painful confession from his father shortly before his death from a heart attack. His father reportedly regretted allowing the family business to leave the Reese family.
“I don’t wanna die because I don’t wanna go to heaven,” Brad recalled his father telling him. When Brad asked why, his father said he did not want to meet his own father because he had “double-crossed him.”
“He made me promise that if he gave me my shares, I would never sell them.”
Reese now considers it his responsibility to correct that perceived betrayal and protect his grandfather’s legacy.
Brad Reese has intensified his criticism of Hershey, accusing the company of weakening the taste of its iconic products with less expensive substitute ingredients
Brad Reese, grandson of peanut butter cup inventor H.B. Reese, believes his grandfather would support his fight over the brand’s future
Reese said his campaign over alleged recipe changes began after a striking confession from his father on his deathbed
“There’s no amount of money that would send me packing. I’m not doing this for money, and I’m not doing it for a position on the board,” Reese said.
“I’m doing it because I believe in it. That’s the most important thing. There’s nothing the Hershey Company can do to financially hurt me.”
However, his position has not won universal support. Reese’s own cousin has described his battle with Hershey as a “nightmare.”
Reese said the unlikely revolt began on Valentine’s Day, when he opened a bag of Reese’s Mini-Hearts.
He expected the familiar flavor but found the candy so unpleasant that he called it “inedible” and threw the entire bag away.
For most consumers, that might have ended the episode. Reese, however, decided to investigate further.
The Florida retiree wrote an angry open letter to Todd Scott, Hershey’s manager of corporate brand and editorial, accusing the company of damaging the Reese’s name.
His main claim was that Hershey had replaced real chocolate in some products with compound chocolate, which uses vegetable oils instead of cocoa butter. He also alleged that traditional peanut butter had been replaced with cheaper “peanut-butter-style crèmes.”
Reese said he realized something had changed last Valentine’s Day after tasting a seasonal product and immediately spitting it out
His accusation was serious: Reese claimed Hershey had compromised the quality of its products by changing their ingredients
For Reese, the issue was about more than an altered ingredient list. He viewed it as a betrayal of the recipe that established his family’s name. Hershey disputes that description.
Brad’s grandfather, Harry Burnett Reese, invented the peanut butter cup and built the candy business that Hershey acquired in 1963.
Although Reese has never worked for Hershey, he has spent years publicly defending his family’s legacy.
A familiar figure in his West Palm Beach retirement community, Reese often wears a bright-orange Reese’s T-shirt and approaches strangers to talk about his grandfather’s invention.
His open letter quickly drew support from consumers who said they, too, had noticed a difference in their favorite candy.
One 61-year-old consumer said he had eaten Reese’s products for most of his life and was repeatedly told that any perceived change was simply the result of aging taste buds.
The complaints soon gained wider attention, appearing across numerous media outlets and eventually catching the notice of late-night host Stephen Colbert.
Yet while many consumers rallied behind Reese, several members of his family were far less receptive to his campaign.
Reese said the family shares were accompanied by an envelope containing the secret recipe that imitators have tried to recreate over the years
The new H.B. Reese Candy Company plant in Hershey, Pennsylvania, on its first day of operations in 1957
His cousin Becky Hilgers, whose mother was H.B. Reese’s youngest daughter and the last of his children to die, sent him an especially angry message.
“Brad, this is your cousin Becky. You have created a nightmare for our family and the company,” she wrote. “It’s embarrassing to the entire Reese clan. Please stop!”
Reese, however, has no plans to retreat, particularly as he confronts his own declining health.
ALSO READ: Why Tech Outages Could Become the New Normal for Months
He said he believes his grandfather would be proud of his efforts today. “He died in West Palm Beach, where I live. He died here, so I’m going to die here,” Reese said.
Hershey responded just four days after Reese published his open letter.
The company said the original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups recipe had not changed, while acknowledging that other products in its portfolio had been reformulated.
Brad’s cousin Becky Hilgers answered his campaign with a forceful public response of her own
Hershey replied four days after Reese’s original post, defending its products while acknowledging that some formulations had changed
Seasonal candy has become a key source of disagreement. Manufacturers sometimes use less expensive vegetable fats in limited-edition products made for Valentine’s Day, Halloween and Christmas.
The dispute grew after TikTok videos showed people bending heated Hershey chocolate bars, prompting further questions about what the products contain.
During an investor presentation in April, Hershey acknowledged changing the coating on some Reese’s products. The company said it would restore products made with compound chocolate to their previous formulations by 2027, while arguing that the changes occurred before the current leadership team took over.
Hershey said Reese does not understand the realities of running a global confectionery business and pointed to its third-quarter results as evidence that consumers continue to enjoy Reese’s products.
Reese remained unconvinced. He expanded his investigation beyond the seasonal products that first triggered his campaign, examining supermarket shelves for signs that other familiar candies had also been changed.
He cited brands such as Mr. Goodbar, Rolo and Almond Joy, questioning whether years of cost-cutting had gradually transformed products consumers had trusted for decades.
But one question continued to dominate the dispute: had the original Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups themselves been reformulated?
Hershey continued to insist that the classic recipe had remained unchanged.
Seasonal products have drawn particular scrutiny because manufacturers may use less expensive vegetable fats for holiday items with a limited production window
According to the company, the classic cups have not changed. That includes the two-, three- and four-cup packs, king-size versions and seasonal shapes such as pumpkins.
The changes involved product extensions, including foil-wrapped molded shapes sold for Valentine’s Day and Easter, Reese’s Minis, Reese’s Thins and Reese’s Sticks.
Those products shifted to a cocoa butter equivalent coating, which under federal labeling rules must be identified as “chocolate candy” rather than milk chocolate.
These coatings replace some or all of the cocoa butter with vegetable oils and are less expensive to produce. A Hershey insider told Fortune that stick-style products such as Reese’s Take5 and Fast Break have used them for years.
Reese has grown increasingly doubtful of Hershey’s explanation. “It’s a brilliant publicity, public relations stunt,” he said.
“I haven’t won anything because it’s total bunk. They’re not going back to the original recipe.”
He told supporters that additional evidence was sitting in his inbox, although he had not yet found the time to organize it.
“They could go back to the original recipe in three days,” he added. “They’re just kicking the can down the road, hoping what I brought up will blow over. It’s a stall.”
Although Hershey maintains that its original peanut butter cup recipe is unchanged, Brad Reese says he is not prepared to accept the company’s assurances
Hilgers said she and the cousins with whom she remains in contact “are all on the same page.”
“I don’t think the integrity of the piece of candy has changed so drastically that it doesn’t taste good and people aren’t buying it,” she previously told Fortune.
“It’s the most recognizable brand that Hershey Company has. We’re still very proud of the candy our grandfather invented, and we trust the Hershey Company to be the caretaker of the brand.”
Reese lives quietly in Century Village, a retirement community for people over 55 in West Palm Beach.
He has also battled non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma for more than 15 years and says he has survived several near-death experiences.
That experience has given him a perspective that makes the sudden burst of media attention feel particularly surreal.
“I take naps in the morning and naps in the afternoon. This is mad crazy for me,” he said.
Although he is still adjusting to the spotlight, Reese said he has no intention of giving up the peaceful retirement he worked hard to build.
“I’d do it all over again just because I can,” he said.
Our News Outlet has contacted Hershey and Becky Hilgers for comment.