Judge Cannon nudged to rule on lingering Mar-a-Lago issue
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: Judge Aileen Cannon (U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida); Right: special counsel Jack Smith (AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite, File)

A second nonprofit group is pushing for the public release of special counsel Jack Smith’s complete report on the Mar-a-Lago investigation concerning President Donald Trump’s alleged mishandling of classified documents after his first presidential term. They have called on U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon to make a decision on their appeal to intervene and overturn an injunction she imposed 171 days ago. This order is currently being leveraged by the DOJ to counter a lawsuit from the New York Times.

Judge Cannon’s injunction on January 21, which prevented the release of Smith’s Mar-a-Lago report, highlighted that Trump valet Waltine Nauta and Mar-a-Lago property manager Carlos de Oliveira had an ongoing appeal in the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Therefore, they “retain — as all parties agree — due process rights to a fair trial that would be jeopardized by public dissemination of Volume II.”

“In short, the Department offers no valid justification for the purportedly urgent desire to release to members of Congress case information in an ongoing criminal proceeding,” wrote Cannon, the judge who dismissed the president’s Espionage Act case and invalidated Smith’s appointment as special counsel last July. “Meanwhile, on the other side of the balance, there are two individuals in this action, each with constitutional rights to a fair trial, who remain subject to a live criminal appeal of this Court’s Order Dismissing the Superseding Indictment.”

At the time of the injunction, the judge noted, the freshly installed Trump administration DOJ had yet to toss the cases against Trump’s now former co-defendants.

“The Department has not sought leave to dismiss that appeal, initiated by the Special Counsel, and there has been no indication by any government official in this case that the Department will not proceed on the Superseding Indictment should it prevail in the Eleventh Circuit or in subsequent proceedings,” Cannon continued.

Just eight days later, however, the DOJ, Nauta, and de Oliveira each agreed to dismiss the appeal, and charges were dropped. The 11th Circuit accordingly responded by jettisoning the case on Feb. 11, 150 days ago.

Nonprofit watchdog American Oversight is now notifying Cannon that it’s also been 90 days since it submitted its last reply in support of intervening and lifting the injunction. The filing came Thursday, three days after fellow would-be intervenor Knight First Amendment Institute likewise nudged Cannon to rule, as if to ask: What’s the holdup?

“To date, there has not been a ruling on American Oversight’s Motion to Intervene, and 90 days have elapsed since American Oversight filed its Reply,” American Oversight’s notice said. “American Oversight respectfully notifies the Court that its Motion to Intervene is ripe for adjudication.”

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox

In an April motion to intervene, American Oversight argued that the Cannon’s injunction “obstructs” the group from “exercising its federal rights” to request Volume II under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).

“The Order was entered to protect the rights of individuals who were then facing a live criminal appeal and possible trial; they no longer face either,” the motion said, referring to Nauta and de Oliveira.

In March, the DOJ answered that the proposed interventions of the Knight Institute and American Oversight should be rejected and that the injunction should stay in place.

But even if Cannon were “inclined to lift” the injunction, she shouldn’t release the full version of Smith’s report because that decision is ultimately up to U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, said the government.

“The United States respectfully submits that the Court should deny the motions to intervene filed by American Oversight and Knight Institute in this closed criminal case. First, neither American Oversight nor Knight Institute has shown that this case fits within the narrow class of circumstances in which courts have previously allowed third parties to intervene in criminal cases,” the DOJ asserted. “This Court should not expand that class.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Father Admits Guilt in Tragic Case of 6-Year-Old Son’s Death

An Indiana man, accused of killing his 6-year-old son, has entered a…

Meet the Brave Train Worker Who Became a Hero During a Harrowing Mass Stabbing: An Inspiring Tale of Courage and Compassion

A British railway employee who suffered severe injuries during a mass stabbing…

Shocking Twist: Man Charged with Murder in Girlfriend’s Death After Months of Investigation

Left: Kelley LaLonde (Obituary). Right: Jonathan Zieroff (Carrollton Township Police Department). A…

Deadly Deception: Unveiling the Eye-Drop Murder Plot Against a Retired Police Chief

Initially, the signs seemed merely like the inevitable toll of aging on…

Churches Accuse Trump Administration of Breaching Mandate on SNAP Benefits

President Donald Trump listens during a swearing in ceremony for Dr. Mehmet…

Bondi Employs Strategic Move to Secure Lindsey Halligan’s Appointment

Left to right: FBI Director James Comey testifies on Capitol Hill in…

Father Confesses to Fatal Abuse: Infant’s Tragic Death Under Investigation

Inset: Joseph Bonito (Wood County Justice Center). Background: The block in Ohio…

Gruesome Texas Tragedy: Man Faces Charges for Allegedly Setting Roommate on Fire

In a chilling case out of Amarillo, Texas, a man faces murder…

Heir to Influential Family Accused of Fatally Attacking Mother with Hammer, Found in Woods Calling for Her

A 20-year-old man from Connecticut, accused of brutally attacking his mother and…

Tragic Case: Father Allegedly Murders 6-Year-Old Son, Blames Child for Self-Inflicted Injuries

Background: News footage of the Elkhart County Courthouse in Goshen, Ind. (WNDU).…

Gas-Scented Suspect Arrested for Alleged Roommate Murder, Police Report

Background: News footage of the aftermath of a trailer fire in Amarillo,…

Deputies Report 73-Year-Old Woman Accused of Disconnecting Husband’s Oxygen Supply

Background: The Rogers County Sheriff”s Office in Claremore, Oklahoma (Google Maps). Inset:…