Main, left to right: Nicholas Caban and Jacob Firestone (Lake County Sheriff’s Office). Inset: Matthew Ascaridis (GoFundMe).
Two men from Illinois are facing lengthy prison sentences after being convicted of the brutal killing of a 45-year-old father, whom they attacked outside his residence, leaving him for dead.
A jury in Lake County reached a verdict on Saturday, finding Nicholas Caban, 23, and Jacob Firestone, 22, guilty on all charges related to the 2022 murder of Matthew Ascaridis. The charges include second-degree murder, among others.
The decision followed a six-day trial where the prosecution presented testimony from over a dozen witnesses, including police officers, medical experts, and other specialists.
Lake County State’s Attorney Eric Rinehart commented that the evidence clearly demonstrated Ascaridis was killed due to “excessive violence” inflicted by Caban and Firestone. He expressed gratitude that the jury paid close attention to both forensic and circumstantial evidence, ultimately leading to the conviction of both defendants on all counts.
According to a press release from the State’s Attorney’s office, the Lake County Major Crimes Task Force responded to several noise complaints at Fort Sheridan Beach in Highland Park. There, authorities discovered Ascaridis deceased at approximately 5:12 a.m. on September 17, 2022, with clear signs of severe trauma.
An autopsy conducted by the Lake County Coroner’s Office revealed that Ascaridis sustained “catastrophic injuries” to his spinal cord, injuries typically associated with high-impact incidents, such as car accidents.
The coroner told jurors that Ascaridis was struck multiple times in the head with so much force that he was left with a lacerated spinal cord, according to testimony cited by the Lake & McHenry County Scanner.
The violence stemmed from a confrontation hours earlier, after Ascaridis left his nearby home to investigate loud noises late the night before. The victim’s wife testified that the couple had been packing for a trip around 11 p.m. when they began hearing “loud noises” near the house. Ascaridis called police twice but was told a response could be delayed. He ultimately went to the beach around 1 a.m. to check things out himself.
Evidence presented at trial showed Ascaridis encountered Caban and Firestone on the beach, leading to what authorities described as a “violent confrontation,” The Record North Shore reported.
Despite the severity of the attack, prosecutors said the defendants did not immediately seek help. Instead, they waited hours before calling 911, leaving Ascaridis “alone on the beach, unable to move, gasping for air” before he died, according to the release.
When police responded to a 911 call at Caban’s home around 5:23 a.m., they found Firestone lying injured in the yard and Caban nearby. Both appeared injured but conscious, authorities said. The men initially claimed that Ascaridis had attacked them and was injured in a fall, but prosecutors argued those accounts were contradicted by medical evidence and DNA recovered from the scene.
Testimony also showed the confrontation began after Ascaridis approached the men about the noise, which included music and activity on the beach, according to Lake & McHenry Scanner.
Caban and Firestone, who were 20 and 18 at the time of the killing, each face between four and 20 years in prison, to be served at 50%. They are currently scheduled to appear in court for their sentencing hearing June 18.
A GoFundMe page for Ascaridis described him as an “incredible husband” to his wife and a “devoted father” to his two children who “always greeted friends and family with his warmth and a smile.”
