Justice Without a Trial: The Kohberger Plea Deal

After Bryan Kohberger was sentenced for the 2022 murders of four University of Idaho students, the Moscow Police Department released a substantial collection of documents regarding the case.

Over 300 documents are part of this release, detailing the initial police response to the King Road scene on the morning of November 13, 2022.

The majority of the data was previously known, but this release represents the first time the original information has been accessible to the public.

Kohberger was sentenced on Tuesday to four consecutive life sentences — without the possibility of parole — for the murders of Xana Kernodle, Ethan Chapin, Madison Mogen, and Kaylee Goncalves. He received an additional 10 years for burglary and was ordered to pay a $270,000 fine.

The initial police narrative of their response to the off-campus house where the murders took place reveals it as “an unconscious call,” with one of the surviving roommate reporting that a “roommate was passed out, not conscious, and not breathing.” Officers who first arrived on the scene quickly determined it was a homicide call.

Officers first found the body of Xana Kernodle on the floor in her bedroom. Officers noted that “it was obvious an intense struggle had occurred,” as Kernodle fought for her life. Ethan Chapin, Kernodle’s boyfriend, was dead in the bed.

Upstairs, the officers found Kaylee Goncalves and Madison Mogen, noting that Goncalves “was unrecognizable as her facial structure was extremely damaged.” Mogen, the officers said, had apparent defensive wounds to her hands and forearms.

Officers immediately began interviewing the surviving roommates and the man they’d called to the scene when they found Kernodle and also spread out into the surrounding area to interview other possible witnesses.

Another officer reported seeing “very large footprints in the snow” outside the students’ home.

“The footsteps went to and from the rear slider door,” the officer wrote. “I observed the foot steps head away from the slider then turn right, around a stump, in the back yard and lead toward the front of the house.”

Last week, Judge Steven Hippler said he would begin the process of unsealing some of the documents sealed by the court after the sentencing.

You May Also Like

Truck Driver Accused of Killing Man in Parking Spot Dispute, Police Say

Inset: Travis Briscoe (Sedgwick County Jail). Background: Police in Wichita, Kansas, investigate…

Man Accused of Stabbing Group Home Worker After Death Threat, Police Say

Inset, left: Luke McLane (Stearns County Sheriff’s Office). Inset, right: Glapoujay Garmondeh…

Sheriff Says Man Killed Roommate and Hid Body in Plastic Barrel

Inset: Daniel W. Russell (Gasconade County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The boat ramp…

Police Say Baby Died After Being Left Home Alone While Mother Worked

Share copy link Inset: Ja’Keisa Knox (Tuscaloosa County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The…

Gainesville Man Charged After Alleged Inappropriate Touching of Child

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Samuel Antonio Mitchell, 39, is facing a…

Federal Judges Strike Down Trump Administration Student Loan Rule Change, Handing Borrowers a Major Win

Background: The U.S. Department of Education building in Washington, D.C., on Dec.…

Police: Wife Helped Fatally Injured Husband to Bed After Son Attacked Couple

Inset: Tyler Lachmann (KOLD/YouTube). Background: The Arizona neighborhood where Tyler Lachmann’s parents…

Homeless Woman Arrested in Alleged Broken Bottle Stabbing Attack on Woman

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Sierra Janae Reynolds, 25, was taken into…