Share this

A New York woman who allegedly drove through a crowd of protestors last year rejected a plea deal on Wednesday that would have spared her from jail.

Kathleen Casillo’s attorney, Oliver Storch, told the New York Post that his client is facing a year in jail if she does not accept prosecutors’ deal which entails her pleading guilty to reckless assault and reckless endangerment. Under that agreement, Casillo, 52, would receive six days of community service and a one-year suspension of her driver license, according to the New York Post.

On December 11, 2020, Casillo allegedly drove through a crowd of demonstrators who were protesting Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in Manhattan. Nine people were injured, and one of the protestors, Tabitha Howell, told amNY that the incident left her with five bulging discs and a traumatic brain injury.

Protestors gathered outside of Manhattan Criminal Court for Casillo’s first appearance to express dissatisfaction in what they believe is Casillo receiving preferential treatment. Speakers accused Assistant District Attorney Andrew Mercer of never contacting seven of the nine victims and essentially giving Casillo the benefit of the doubt, according to amNY.

However, Storch told the Post that the unruly crowd put his client and her daughter in danger as they smashed her car’s windows.

“This was an angry mob that descended upon this mother and her daughter, and she panicked,” he told the news outlet.

Meanwhile, Mercer denied some of the victims’ recent allegations, telling amNY in a statement, “Our office has attempted to speak with every victim in this case.”

Casillo is due back in court on January 18.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Listen to the latest episode:

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most — your children.

[Featured image: Twitter]

Source: This post first appeared on

Share this
You May Also Like

Betsy Ann DeJesus Made Man Dance During Robbery: Deputies

From left, clockwise: Betsy Ann DeJesus, Blanca Mejiamedina, and Noah Navarro A…

Frank Forte Stabbed Catherine Forte to Death: Reports

A man allegedly stabbed his wife to death and then killed himself,…

Ashley Richards Loses Teaching Job After Child Abuse Charge

A Florida preschool teacher is at reportedly out of a job —…

Where Is Convicted Murderer Matthew Hoffman Now?

Teo Tarras/Shutterstock In 2010, Tina Herrmann, her friend Stephanie Sprang, and Herrmann’s…

What Was Elsie Ralph’s Life After The Murder Of Her Three Children?

David McGreavy has to strictly follow the rules of exclusion zones, which…

The Tragic Life And Death Of Charles Manson Jr.

After Charles Manson died in 2017, three individuals petitioned the court for…

Bus Driver Accused of Stalking 8-Year-Old Boy, Walking around Child’s Home at Night – Crime Online

A school bus driver is accused of stalking an 8-year-old boy and…

2-Year-Old Boy Dies After Critical Shooting; Police Search for Suspect – Crime Online

A toddler found critically wounded earlier this week with a gunshot wound…