Indiana coroner says police 'dropped the ball' in Fox Hollow Farm serial killer case

An Indiana coroner examining the Fox Hollow Farm serial killings remarked that law enforcement “dropped the ball” during the initial investigation in the 1990s.

In April, Hamilton County Coroner Jeff Jellison revealed that his office had identified human remains at Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, Indiana, as those of Daniel Thomas Halloran, marking him as the tenth victim of the alleged serial killer Herb Baumeister, who is suspected of having at least 25 victims.

Jellison expressed to Fox News Digital that he believes law enforcement did not handle the case correctly during their original inquiry.

“I think originally in the investigation, law enforcement did a good job of excavating the remains, but I think as time went on in the investigation, our county really dropped the ball,” Jellison said.

Investigators searching on the Fox Hollow Farm grounds.

Authorities dig for human bones in a wooded area on the Fox Hollow Farm in Westfield, July 2, 1996. (Rich Miller/Indy Star-USA Today Network/Imagn)

Jellison said he “cannot imagine” that law enforcement would push the financial burden of a DNA test onto a victim’s family in today’s world.

“These remains represent victims in a homicide, in a murder. So, to say to the families that if you want to know if your loved one was a victim of a murder, I mean, that’s a tragedy in and of its own,” Jellison said. “I think we’re better today. We’re more sensitive today to victims and family members of victims of crimes.” 

The Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office declined to comment.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

You May Also Like

Karmelo Anthony photographed with guns as docs reveal alleged history of rage, threats and violence

Attorney Debunks Key Karmelo Anthony Filing Misconception in Track Meet Murder Case

A 75-page court filing outlining alleged threats, gun images and violent text…
$147K reward offered to unmask mystery tree poisoning suspect

$147K Reward Offered to Identify Suspect in Mystery Tree Poisoning

A $147,000 reward is being offered in Lake Tahoe’s famously affluent Incline…
Nolan Wells' death ‘consistent with drowning,’ no evidence it was criminal or racially motivated: grand jury

Grand Jury Finds Nolan Wells’ Death Consistent With Drowning

A grand jury has determined that Nolan Wells’ death was consistent with…
World leaders descend on New York for UNGA — but who really has America’s ear?

UNGA 2026: Which World Leaders Have America’s Ear in New York?

— More than 100 presidents and prime ministers are set to arrive…
‘Disgruntled' car owner slaps ‘shame sticker’ on NYC sanitation car

Disgruntled Car Owner Slaps ‘Shame Sticker’ on NYC Sanitation Car

A frustrated New York City driver appears to have taken aim at…
Tourists seeking 'dramatic' photo on isolated beach trapped by incoming tide

Tourists Trapped by Rising Tide Chasing Dramatic Beach Photo

Three tourists seeking a picture-perfect view at Oregon’s Lost Boy Beach instead…
Chicago gas prices climb above $5 per-gallon, according to GasBuddy survey

Chicago Gas Prices Surge Above $5 a Gallon, GasBuddy Says

CHICAGO () — Chicago drivers are once again confronting painful prices at…
The Essex Files: Josh Shapiro’s Medicaid Red Tape Hurts Pennsylvania’s Truly Disabled

Shapiro’s Medicaid Red Tape Hurts Disabled Pennsylvanians

Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro’s administration is facing a lawsuit over Medicaid rules…
‘American Idol’ contestant’s 100K texts with mistress show motive in wife’s murder, prosecutors say

Prosecutors: 100K Texts Show Idol Contestant’s Wife Murder Motive

Text messages surface in murder trial with former ‘American Idol’ contestant Former…
Trump meets with Macron in New York ahead of United Nations General Assembly 

Trump Meets Macron in New York Ahead of UN General Assembly

President Trump met with French President Emmanuel Macron in New York on…
Office of Emergency Management and Communications to launch CentralSquare Technologies Chicago 911 call dispatch system

Chicago Launches CentralSquare 911 Call Dispatch System

CHICAGO () — Chicago’s Office of Emergency Management and Communications will begin…
Trump strikes back at TV boycott with a dramatic move of his own

Trump Counters TV Boycott With Dramatic New Move

WASHINGTON — President Trump has launched a counteroffensive against major television networks…