Jacksonville public records activist must pay SAO $134K after losing lawsuit

Jacksonville Public Records Activist Ordered to Pay SAO 4,000 After Lawsuit Loss

Curtis Lee has lost a lawsuit he initiated in 2020, in which he claimed that the State Attorney’s Office breached the Florida Public Records Act. As a result, he is now required to cover the agency’s legal expenses.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — A Jacksonville resident, who was unsuccessful in his public records lawsuit against the Fourth Judicial Circuit State Attorney’s Office (SAO), is now obligated to pay $134,000 for the agency’s legal costs, as determined by a judge last week.

The outcome of the case was announced in a news release shared with First Coast News on Wednesday.

In 2020, Curtis Lee accused the SAO of not adhering to the Florida Public Records Act (PRA) by failing to promptly address his request for documents related to an investigation concerning a judge. His lawsuit also pointed out problems with the processes of handling public records and criticized the court for charging him “arbitrary and capricious” fees for previous requests for public records.

Lee is a former lawyer and successfully sued government agencies in the past over public records laws.

In September 2022, the court ruled that Lee failed to prove the SAO withheld records in response to his request and did not violate the PRA.

The next month, the SAO filed a motion to have Lee reimburse the agency’s legal bills needed to fight his lawsuit, which they said were more than $130,000.

The agency’s move marked a test of a Florida amendment made to public records laws in 2017, which allows government agencies to pursue compensation for legal costs if the court can prove a lawsuit or records request was made for any “improper” or “frivolous purpose.”

The court sided with the SAO’s argument, which said Lee harbored animosity for the agency and its employees, which stemmed from Lee’s admitting he felt mistreated by them.

“The lawsuit was not a vehicle to obtain public records, and Mr. Lee simply had no basis for believing the SAO had violated the PRA,” a court order states.

The court noted that Lee had filed the lawsuit after voluntarily dismissing a previous one with similar claims, and the SAO attempted to work with him to provide the records he requested. 

“The SAO’s counsel communicated that position to Mr. Lee in writing on at least three occasions before Mr. Lee filed this lawsuit,” the order states. “If Mr. Lee’s true goal was to obtain public records, he simply had to make a clear request to the SAO. No reasonable person would have resorted to a lawsuit under these circumstances.”

An expert witness testified in favor of Lee that it’s not unusual for requesters to suspect more records could exist after receiving a response that no such records exist. However, the court said a general suspicion of the government is not a sufficient reason to file a lawsuit.

Ultimately, the court concluded Lee’s lawsuit lacked legal justification and a judge has ordered him to reimburse the SAO the taxpayer dollars the agency paid to fight his lawsuit.

“Our Public Records team continues to do an outstanding job serving the public,” said State Attorney Melissa Nelson in a statement shared Wednesday. “This litigation wasted office resources and taxpayer money, and it was totally unnecessary. We are grateful that the taxpayer dollars the office has been forced to spend on this lawsuit will be returned and can be used for their intended purpose.” 

Some advocates have argued that the outcome of Lee’s case could set a precedent for how public records laws are enforced in Florida and the future of public records lawsuits against government agencies.

You May Also Like

Graffiti returns to Yolo County’s Stevenson Bridge after $8.3M fix

Graffiti Returns to Yolo County’s Stevenson Bridge After $8.3M Repairs

California taxpayers have spent $8.3 million restoring a graffiti-covered landmark, but the…
Causes of death revealed for Indiana family of four found dead after daughter made haunting 911 call

Indiana Family of Four’s Death Causes Revealed After Daughter’s 911 Call

Preliminary autopsy findings show that a Purdue University professor and her two…
Texas Democrats push high-speed rail despite California struggles

Texas Democrats Renew Push for High-Speed Rail Despite California Project Challenges

Democrats who helped turn Texas blue are already pitching a familiar California-style…
Fairfield Spirit Halloween shooting survivor speaks out

Fairfield Spirit Halloween Shooting Survivor Speaks Out After Attack

A father’s Halloween outing with his young son became a scene of…
Swift assurances from officials after wave of nationwide outages raises questions, expert says

Officials’ Swift Assurances After Nationwide Outages Raise Questions, Expert Says

A series of high-profile disruptions affecting critical parts of American life unfolded…
Denmark accuses Russia of plotting to kill Ukrainian American rapper on Danish soil

Denmark Says Russia Plotted to Kill Ukrainian-American Rapper

Denmark’s security and intelligence agency, PET, has accused Russia of trying to…
NYC OsamaSon's concertgoers injured in crowd crush during rapper Terminal 5 show

Rapper OsamaSon’s Fans Injured in Crowd Crush at NYC Show

At least four concertgoers were injured in a dangerous crowd surge that…
The Essex Files: Melania Trump’s Series Offers a Rare Window Into the Private Life of a First Lady

The Essex Files Reveals Melania Trump’s Private Life as First Lady

Prime Video’s new two-part documentary series, “Melania: The Series,” gives viewers a…
Trump commits to look at Barry Bonds Hall of Fame snubs after Pete Rose pardon

Trump to Review Barry Bonds Hall of Fame Snub After Rose Pardon

After granting a posthumous pardon to baseball icon Pete Rose, President Trump…
Trump admin quietly releases government Bigfoot files

Trump Administration Quietly Releases U.S. Government Bigfoot Files

Bigfoot is making an unexpected appearance in newly released government records. Documents…
Alabama woman pleads guilty after reportedly using smart glasses to target drug trial witnesses

Alabama Woman Pleads Guilty to Using Smart Glasses to Target Drug Trial Witnesses

An Alabama woman has admitted using Meta smart glasses to covertly film…
Princeton student detained by ICE news: Neuroscience Ph.D. student Eva Yi Xie detained at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport after attending Society for Neuroscience conference

Princeton Neuroscience Ph.D. Student Eva Yi Xie Detained by ICE

PRINCETON, N.J. — A Princeton University doctoral student was taken into federal…