Critical witness puts case against Karen Read 'on life support,' lawyer says

Key Witness Weakens Case Against Karen Read, Lawyer Claims

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Karen Read’s legal team is aiming to capitalize on momentum from a surprising police witness who testified that her taillight was less damaged when he assisted in seizing it with a warrant, compared to photos taken after it reached the Canton Police Department, where it was initially towed.

Taillight fragments weren’t found at the crime scene until later, too, and her defense’s implication is that they could have been planted there.

Wednesday marks the 27th day of Read’s retrial on murder and other charges in the January 2022 death of her then-boyfriend, Boston cop John O’Keefe.

Grace Edwards, a Massachusetts defense lawyer also monitoring the case, described Barros’ testimony as a “bombshell” and stated that the surprise in trial 1 represented “a clear Brady violation” – a term referring to the obligation of prosecutors to disclose exculpatory evidence to the defense.

“The fact that a police officer went to the Omni Hotel to meet with the defense team of a defendant on trial for murder clearly suggests he wanted to share his account,” she told Fox News Digital.

Dr. Judson Welcher, an expert for the prosecution, explained to jurors how he found that O’Keefe appeared to have been struck in the arm by the back corner of Read’s SUV before he fell to the ground and fractured the back of his skull.

Christina Hanley, an analyst with the state police’s crime lab, testified that investigators recovered plastic fragments from O’Keefe’s clothing that were a match with the broken taillight or something made of the same material.

Read could face life in prison if convicted of the top charge, second-degree murder. 

You May Also Like

ABC7 to livestream 2026 Chicago River Swim special on Sunday, Sept. 20, supporting ALS research and youth swim education

ABC7 to Livestream 2026 Chicago River Swim Supporting ALS Research and Youth Swim Education

CHICAGO () — The 2026 Chicago River Swim was called off Sunday,…
NYC nut who tried to kidnap 4-year-old off street has disturbing past: authorities

NYC Man in 4-Year-Old Abduction Attempt Has Troubling Past

A woman accused of trying to take a police officer’s 4-year-old son…
Patrick Clancy and new wife Rachel Danis reveal they're starting a family in '60 Minutes' interview

Patrick Clancy and Wife Rachel Danis Share Plans to Start a Family in 60 Minutes Interview

Patrick Clancy and his wife, Rachel Danis, have announced that they are…
San Francisco woman gives birth by the side of the road after getting stuck in city traffic

San Francisco Woman Gives Birth Roadside After Traffic Delays Hospital Trip

A San Francisco couple’s trip to the hospital turned into an unexpected…
Ukraine targets Russia with over 1,000 drones, killing 2 as Moscow holds last day of elections

Ukraine Launches Over 1,000 Drones at Russia as Moscow Ends Elections, 2 Killed

Ukraine launched a massive wave of missiles and more than 1,000 drones…
DOJ charges 16 in illegal voting probe across multiple states

DOJ Charges 16 in Illegal Voting Investigation Spanning States

The Department of Justice has charged 16 people across several states in…
Cranky Dorkfest at LAX draws plane spotters, aviation fans and In-N-Out lovers

Cranky Dorkfest at LAX Unites Plane Spotters and In-N-Out Fans

Few things can bring a crowd of aviation enthusiasts to Los Angeles…
Hamas allegedly built weapons depots across Europe, planned terror attacks as Oct 7 anniversary neared

Hamas Allegedly Built European Weapons Depots, Planned Attacks

Germany’s federal prosecutor has indicted seven people accused of obtaining weapons for…
Kentucky babysitter fatally abuses baby, leaves body stuffed in couch -- with alarming injuries: cops

Kentucky Babysitter Charged After Baby Found Stuffed in Couch

A 19-year-old Kentucky babysitter allegedly fatally abused an 11-month-old boy, leaving bruises…
Trump, Iranian president converge on NYC for ‘dramatic’ UN showdown as Tehran faces tight restrictions

Trump and Iranian President Arrive in New York for High-Stakes UN Talks Amid Tehran Restrictions

President Donald Trump and Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian will be in New…
18 suspects in killing of Haiti's president being extradited to Florida for trial

18 Suspects in Haiti President Jovenel Moïse Assassination Extradited to Florida for Trial

Eighteen suspects arrested in connection with the July 2021 assassination of Haitian…
Lindsay Clancy fixation and alleged plot to poison husband emerge as accused mom claims psychosis

Alleged Killer Corie Walsh Barred From Home, Risk May Change

An Illinois judge has determined that Corie Walsh is too great a…