Prosecutor: Women Jurors May Sway Lindsay Clancy Verdict - Internewscast Journal
Prosecutor: Women Jurors May Sway Lindsay Clancy Verdict

A South Carolina legislator who helped secure the conviction of Susan Smith in one of the nation’s most notorious child-murder cases says the makeup of Lindsay Clancy’s jury could create an unexpected dynamic — particularly because female jurors may not respond to her defense with the sympathy some observers anticipate.

Clancy, 36, is facing three first-degree murder charges in the deaths of her children — Cora, Dawson and Callan — all of whom were under the age of 6 when they were found strangled inside the family’s home in January 2023.

Her legal team has argued that Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed the children.

Plymouth, MA - August 11: Lindsay Clancy sits next to her defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, during her murder trial at Plymouth Superior Court on August 11, 2026. (Photo by Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

Lindsay Clancy is seated beside her defense lawyer, Kevin Reddington, during her murder trial at Plymouth Superior Court on Aug. 11, 2026. (Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

The trial is nearing a pivotal stage, with testimony expected to conclude Wednesday and closing arguments likely to begin Thursday. After that, the case will be handed to the jury. The panel selected for the proceedings includes 12 women and six men, though only 12 jurors will take part in deliberations; the remaining members are alternates who will be released before the jury begins its work.

The comparison to Susan Smith stems from another high-profile case involving a mother convicted in the deaths of her young children. Smith, a South Carolina mother, was found guilty of killing her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, after prosecutors said she strapped them into her vehicle and allowed it to roll into a lake. At trial, prosecutors argued that one motive was Smith’s relationship with a man who did not want to be involved with a woman who had children. She received a life sentence.

Lindsay Clancy's backyard, filled with children's toys.

An exterior view of Patrick and Lindsay Clancy’s home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on Wednesday, Feb. 15, 2023. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

Rep. Tommy Pope, now speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House of Representatives, was one of the prosecutors in the Smith case. Speaking with News Outlet, he said the female jurors in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial could prove tougher to persuade than the defense might expect.

“For the most part, the women were the ones that said, you know, when I had my kids, I went through hell, or I went through depression, or I battled this, or I was overwhelmed. But they’re the most important thing in my life,” Pope said. “And so, strange twist, while a woman may have even faced postpartum depression, she may have overcome it and then be less sympathetic to Clancy.”

Clancy with child

Lindsay Clancy, who is on trial for killing her three children, Cora, Dawson and Callan, in a family photo entered as evidence. (Plymouth Superior Court)

On the flip side, Pope said Clancy’s current physical condition might complicate things for the prosecution in an unexpected way.

“A weird mix, too, is having her in the courtroom, whether she intentionally injured herself or, as the prosecution said, tried to slide down and just got injured. You have somebody that’s now paralyzed, which obviously doesn’t equate to killing three children,” Pope said. “But some jurors, and I would think maybe even more so men, would think, well, she’s already punished. She’s in a wheelchair. So in a strange twist, it could almost be the opposite.”

1a0c238a-Susan Smith infanticide case

Susan Smith was convicted on July 22, 1995 of murdering her two sons, 3-year-old Michael Daniel Smith and 14-month-old Alexander Tyler Smith. Initially, Smith claimed that a Black man carjacked her with the two boys still inside her vehicle. But her story unraveled, and the woman admitted that she let her vehicle roll into a lake with the boys strapped inside. (Getty Images)

Prosecutors on Tuesday continued to challenge the psychosis argument that Clancy’s defense attorney says frees her from criminal responsibility for her children’s deaths.

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy. The three children were killed at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

Gregory Saathoff, a forensic psychiatrist at the University of Virginia who consults for the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit, told jurors that Clancy’s self-described auditory hallucinations were “very unusual.”

“What was significant to me is that she had not spoken about hearing voices before to any of the mental health professionals, psychiatrists, nurse practitioners, physicians and staff in the emergency department, or at McLean,” Saathoff said.

“This was the first time she reported that, and that she experienced an auditory hallucination, according to what she told me. So that was unusual. And then what was very unusual was the fact that the voice stopped with the strangling of her youngest son,” he added.

In another blow to Clancy’s defense, prosecutors asked psychologist Kirk Heilbrun whether someone hearing a command hallucination could still conform their conduct to the law.

“In some cases they can,” he responded.

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer, Kevin J. Reddington speaks to reporters outside Plymouth Superior Court.

Kevin J. Reddington addresses the media as he arrives at Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Mass., on Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2026. Reddington is representing Lindsay Clancy on murder charges in the deaths of her three children. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

Earlier in the week, Clancy’s defense called its own experts and argued she’s not criminally responsible. Dr. Phillip Resnick, a forensic psychiatrist, testified that Clancy killed her children while she was experiencing a “command hallucination,” stating she felt like “a puppet.”

“Not only did she hear a command, but she felt that her body was taken over by an external force where she was in a dream state and did not have control of her own body. It was almost like she was a puppet and someone else was pulling the strings,” Resnick said.

Outside the courtroom on Tuesday, one person told News Outlet she was there in support of Lindsay Clancy because “I’ve always been aware that mental health is something that’s woefully in need of funding, education, all that.”

“This trial has really made a lot of us realize just how bad things are. Obviously, a really sad story and hard to listen to at times. But if this moves the needle just a teeny tiny bit, and women start to experience more support, then I’m here for that. I was just telling my friend that when I had my children and left the hospital, nobody really said anything about postpartum, you know, be on the lookout for things. And…you know, we just had to figure it out ourselves. It shouldn’t be that way. And I hope things change,” the woman said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Zoo shares autopsy findings following Fiona the hippo’s heartbreaking death

Cincinnati Zoo Releases Autopsy Findings After Fiona the Hippo’s Death

The Cincinnati Zoo released new autopsy details Friday following the death of…
NYC ex-con arrested for good Samaritan's murder during dog fight

NYC Ex-Convict Arrested for Killing Good Samaritan During Dog Fight

A convicted ex-offender with at least 10 previous arrests has been charged…
South Carolina duo charged in road rage murder of Scott Spivey

Two South Carolina Men Charged in Road Rage Killing of Scott Spivey

Two South Carolina men have been charged with murder in the road-rage…
College student accused of locking fellow student in bedroom during attack as roommates raced to save her

College Student Accused of Locking Peer in Bedroom During Attack

A college student is facing multiple criminal charges after investigators alleged that…
Suspect in alleged rape of LSU student killed by car fights to keep mom’s warning texts out of December trial

Man Accused of Raping, Killing LSU Student Fights Mom’s Texts

‘We wear it to honor her’: Madison Brooks’ mother condemns defense effort…
San Pedro grooming salon offers $2,000 reward for Maine Coon cat missing after fire

San Pedro Salon Offers $2,000 Reward for Maine Coon Missing After Fire

A beloved Maine Coon cat vanished after a fire broke out at…
NYC Mayor Mamdani announces delayed plan to close city's largest jail

NYC Mayor Mamdani Delays Plan to Close Rikers Island, City’s Largest Jail

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said Friday on X, ahead of…
Chicago shooting: Bike path shooting near Belmont Harbor connected to 2 deadly Rogers Park shootings: Chicago police

Chicago Police Link Belmont Harbor Bike Path Shooting to 2 Fatal Rogers Park Shootings

CHICAGO (AP) — A man critically injured in a shooting on a…
Iran regime's execution spree continues as twins face death penalty, decades in prison after alleged torture

Iran Execution Spree: Twins Face Death, Prison After Torture

Two Iranian twin sisters jailed for taking part in anti-government protests came…
Stony Brook-bound QB leads Ward Melville to Suffolk championship

Stony Brook-Bound Quarterback Leads Ward Melville to Suffolk Title

Hudson Philbrick has transformed the Ward Melville Patriots into a force to…
Texas inmate's execution takes over an hour as prison staff struggle to find suitable veins

Texas Execution Delayed Over an Hour as Staff Struggle to Find Veins

A Texas inmate’s execution took more than an hour Thursday after prison…
New Mexico boy who fatally shot teen neighbor Keinerlein Rangel seen in new chaotic video

Chaotic New Video of New Mexico Boy Who Fatally Shot Keinerlein Rangel

Home security footage captured the horrifying moment a 10-year-old boy allegedly followed…