Sally Yates' Cornell alleged gang rape review could scrutinize crucial police interview, attorney says

A previously undisclosed portion of a Cornell University police interview could become a central focus of an independent review into an alleged rape case involving members of the Ivy League school’s Chi Phi fraternity. Local prosecutors say they did not receive the complete interview before initially deciding not to file charges.

Cornell’s trustees have appointed former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to lead a broad examination of the university’s response to allegations made in October 2024. The review follows Cornell’s internal proceedings, which resulted in several students being expelled or suspended.

In a November 2024 interview with Cornell University Police, the woman identified in court documents as Jane Doe said, “I can say with 100% confidence I was raped,” according to a transcript obtained by CBS News. She also characterized subsequent sexual activity as coercive and said she had been “completely and totally incapacitated.”

Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten said prosecutors instead reviewed a six-page sworn statement portraying Doe’s drug use and involvement in the sexual activity as voluntary and consensual.

Van Houten said his office was not initially given the full police interview. After reviewing additional material, he told CBS News last week that the more complete account “changes the landscape for me.”

Split image of Cornell University's Tudor-style Chi Phi fraternity house on the left and former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates wearing a purple blazer on the right.

Former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates (right) is examining Cornell University’s response to sexual assault allegations involving members of its Chi Phi fraternity, whose house is shown at left. (Ryan Murphy/Getty Images; Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Scott Iseman, a New York lawyer who has represented students accused of campus sexual misconduct, said Yates may compare the complete police interview with Doe’s sworn statement, later testimony and evidence collected during Cornell’s disciplinary investigation.

“Those full recorded interviews, I can tell you from experience, have a treasure trove of information that are really, really important to exactly what happened,” Iseman said.

He said it would not be unusual for a fuller interview to contain details capable of altering the direction of a case. “It wouldn’t surprise me if there was additional information in there that would have changed the trajectory of this case because that happens all the time,” Iseman said.

Iseman said any inconsistencies between Doe’s complete interview and the shorter sworn statement could prove especially important to Yates’ review.

“Law enforcement is supposed to make sure that all salient facts are included in that sworn statement,” he said.

Cornell said its police department gave prosecutors Doe’s sworn statement and a screenshot from Snapchat in 2024. The university described that exchange as a routine step when officials believe a potential crime may have occurred.

Iseman emphasized that he had not seen the full interview, which has not been released publicly, and therefore could not assess whether any omitted details were significant. It also remains unknown why the complete interview was not originally sent to Van Houten’s office. News Outlet contacted Cornell University Police and the Tompkins County District Attorney’s Office seeking an explanation.

Cornell said Yates and her team will be able to review relevant records and case files and interview university employees and leaders. The examination will assess the school’s response under its original Title IX process, which addresses potential violations of university sexual misconduct rules rather than criminal offenses.

The police interview is only one area Yates could investigate, according to Iseman. He said the review might also uncover witnesses who were not interviewed, overlooked text messages or social media posts, and other evidence that was absent from Cornell’s initial inquiry.

“There’s a lot that potentially she could uncover,” Iseman said.

Still, he warned that the existence of unanswered questions does not by itself show Cornell acted improperly.

“It may have all been done very appropriately by Cornell. We don’t know yet,” he said.

Cornell University

Former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates is leading a review of Cornell University’s handling of the allegations. (TW Farlow/Getty Images)

Cornell has stood by its response, citing an extensive internal investigation that included more than 50 interviews and 12 days of disciplinary hearings.

University President Michael Kotlikoff said two of the seven accused students were expelled, two were suspended for at least two semesters, one had graduated before discipline could be imposed and two were found not responsible for sexual misconduct.

Cornell said both the accuser and accused students had opportunities to review evidence, testify and challenge the findings through an appeals process.

Yates was brought in after the case erupted into a national firestorm following Doe’s Sept. 16 lawsuit, which laid out graphic allegations that seven Chi Phi fraternity members drugged and sexually assaulted her during a night involving alcohol, drugs and group sex at their fraternity house in October 2024. The allegations have since sparked protests on campus while New York Attorney General Letitia James’ office is conducting a separate criminal investigation.

The men have denied wrongdoing, with some maintaining the sexual activity was consensual and others denying they participated. No criminal charges have been filed against the seven men.

Yates’ investigation extends beyond the Chi Phi case to examine how Cornell handles sexual misconduct allegations across campus, including its oversight of fraternities, sororities and other student organizations.

Her team at law firm King & Spalding will also assess Cornell’s practices against federal and state laws and examine whether the university followed its own procedures in responding to the Chi Phi allegations.

Any new or previously overlooked evidence identified during the review could potentially be shared with James’ office, Iseman said, though Yates herself has no authority to bring charges.

Thousands of Cornell University students and others from the Cornell community fill Ho Plaza

Thousands of Cornell University students and others from the Cornell community fill Ho Plaza for the Justice for Survivors protest hosted by twenty student organizations Monday, Oct. 5, 2026. (Matt Burkhartt/For The Washington Post via Getty Images)

Her findings could also lead to recommendations for improving Cornell’s procedures, even if the university is found to have followed its existing rules. Cornell said Yates will report her findings and recommendations to a special committee of its Board of Trustees, which intends to share the results with the university community.

Yates has tackled explosive misconduct allegations before.

Her 2022 investigation into women’s professional soccer exposed widespread sexual harassment, coercion and abuse by coaches, along with failures by league officials to act on complaints.

What began as an investigation into individual coaches exposed much wider problems across women’s soccer, prompting a series of recommendations for sweeping reforms that U.S. Soccer subsequently pledged to implement.

The Cornell case also highlights a wider debate over the legal protections available to students accused of serious sexual misconduct, even as universities have the power to expel them.

John R. Grasso, a Rhode Island criminal defense attorney and former police officer who has represented accused students for two decades, argued that campus disciplinary proceedings can carry life-altering consequences without offering the same legal protections available in criminal court.

“When I defend a student on campus, we don’t have any right to discovery. We can’t compel the production of anything,” Grasso said.

He said those limitations can make it difficult for attorneys to obtain potentially important text messages, photographs and other evidence that might support an accused student’s defense.

Grasso also described the difficult choice students can face when university disciplinary proceedings and criminal investigations overlap: participating in campus proceedings and potentially making statements that could affect a criminal case, or remaining silent and risking disciplinary consequences.

“I have a right to remain silent, but if I don’t participate, I’m getting found responsible,” he said, describing the dilemma he has encountered representing students.

cornell-rape-chi-phi-fox-news_097

General view of the now-shuttered Chi Phi fraternity house at 107 Edgemoor Lane in Ithaca, NY., Tueaday, October 6, 2026. (Richard Beetham for News Outlet) ( )

Grasso said the consequences of campus sexual misconduct allegations can extend far beyond disciplinary hearings, describing students whose education, reputations and emotional well-being have suffered even when they were ultimately cleared.

“Bad things happen to the accused the minute a complaint is filed against them on campus. Really bad things,” he said.

With the allegations now under renewed scrutiny, Iseman stressed the importance of keeping an open mind about what actually happened.

“Just because the allegations are salacious or dramatic does not mean that’s what happened,” Iseman said. “So people need to keep an open mind.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

China could exploit US technology to threaten American forces, congressional watchdog leaders warn

Congressional Leaders Warn China Could Exploit US Tech Against Forces

China could use espionage, unauthorized access and other means to obtain advanced…
Pentagon: Reinvigorated Defense Relationship with Canada Is Needed

Pentagon Calls for Revitalized US-Canada Defense Partnership

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s reported shift toward China and Europe is…
Alabama man Reuben Gulley acquitted in murder of TikTok star Ophelia Nichols' teen son

Alabama Man Reuben Gulley Acquitted in Murder of TikTok Star Ophelia Nichols’ Teen Son

An Alabama man who claimed self-defense for shooting TikTok star Ophelia Nichols’…
Bayer paying out $7.25B in settlement over weed killer's link to cancer

Bayer to Pay $7.25 Billion in Roundup Weed Killer Cancer Settlement

Bayer, the agrochemical company behind Roundup, will pay as much as $7.25…
Israeli shepherds report suspected 'agricultural terror' targeting livestock

Israeli Shepherds Report Suspected ‘Agricultural Terror’ on Livestock

A string of suspected animal-poisoning attacks has alarmed Israeli security officials, farmers…
Stocks enter correction territory, driven by a deepening tech rout

Stocks Enter Correction Territory as Deepening Tech Sell-Off Drags Markets Lower

Technology shares suffered a sharp sell-off Friday, wiping out the optimism surrounding…
Utah mommy blogger Ruby Franke's daughter begs parole board not to let her out of prison: 'she is a monster'

Ruby Franke’s Daughter Urges Parole Board to Keep Utah Mommy Blogger in Prison: ‘She Is a Monster’

Shari Franke, the oldest daughter of convicted child abuser and former Utah…
Texas execution took over an hour as staff struggled to find vein:

Texas Execution Lasted Over an Hour as Staff Sought a Vein

Texas carried out the execution of Reinaldo Dennes on Thursday after prison…
Denmark accuses Russia of plotting to kill Ukrainian American rapper on Danish soil

Denmark Says Russia Plotted to Kill Ukrainian-American Rapper

Denmark’s security and intelligence agency, PET, has accused Russia of trying to…
Florida man sentenced to death for 'cold, calculated' murder of attorney whose body was never found

Florida Man Gets Death for Attorney Murder, Body Never Found

A former Florida plastic surgeon who represented himself in court was sentenced…
Protesters call for regime change in Iran following deadly crash that killed 13 oil and gas workers

Iran Protests Demand Regime Change After Crash Kills 13 Oil and Gas Workers

Hundreds of people took to the streets of western Iran on Tuesday…
$3.3M Encino home targeted by burglars in home invasion

Burglars Target $3.3M Encino Home in Brazen Home Invasion

Two burglars broke into a $3.3 million home in Encino on Friday…