Stepdad did not call daughter of missing US woman in Bahamas until 'more than 24 hours' after she disappeared at sea: report

It took nearly a full day for Lynette Hooker’s daughter to learn that her mother had gone missing at sea. The news was broken by her stepfather, Brian Hooker, during a phone call, as reported recently.

Brian, 58, informed Lynette’s daughter, Karli Aylesworth, about the troubling situation on Sunday. The mysterious case began when Lynette, a 55-year-old woman from Michigan, disappeared after falling overboard during a dinghy ride on Saturday evening.

A source close to the family shared with the Daily Mail that this conversation took place over 24 hours after the incident. “We don’t know why the delay happened. Whether he was occupied with the search or for other reasons, we’re simply unsure,” the source stated.

The incident occurred after 7:30 p.m. on Saturday while the couple was heading to their yacht near Elbow Cay. Brian didn’t make it back to shore until around 4 a.m. on Sunday because Lynette had fallen overboard with the boat key, which stopped the engine.

Authorities reported that strong currents swept Lynette away, and Brian lost sight of her. He explained to law enforcement that he had to paddle the dinghy back to shore, as he had no means to restart the engine.

Strong currents dragged her away and Brian lost sight of her, according to authorities. The husband told law enforcement he was forced to paddle the boat back to shore with no way to rev up the engine.  

When Brian finally alerted Aylesworth, she claimed to NBC News his voice was “monotone and relaxed.”

“I was in shock,” she said. “I was like, my mom’s missing? Like, what?”

He also left a voicemail for Aylesworth to let her know searchers found the flotation device he threw to Lynette when she went in the water, CBS News reported.

While Brian has not been accused of wrongdoing, Aylesworth finds her mom’s disappearance suspicious and claimed to “Fox and Friends” on Wednesday her stepfather has a “bunch of anger he hasn’t processed.”

She told NBC News Lynette and Brian’s relationship includes a “history of not getting along, especially when they drink.”

The effort to find Lynette has morphed from a rescue search to a recovery operation.

Attempts to reach Brian have not been successful. He also has not replied to other outlets’ requests.

Brian, in a statement on his Facebook page, said he was “heartbroken” over his wife’s disappearance. 

You May Also Like
NBA Draft 2026: Chicago Bulls could take Caleb Wilson, Cam Boozer in First Round after Nic Claxton trade

2026 NBA Draft: Bulls Eye Caleb Wilson or Cam Boozer After Nic Claxton Trade Shakeup

CHICAGO (WLS) — The NBA Draft tips off Tuesday night in New…
Chicago White Sox host Joliet Miracle League players with special needs at The Rate field

Chicago White Sox Welcome Joliet Miracle League Players With Special Needs to Rate Field

CHICAGO (WLS) — With the Chicago White Sox sitting in a tie…
Former FBI agent claims investigators are closing in on 'porch guy' in Nancy Guthrie case -- leaving Megyn Kelly stunned

Megyn Kelly Stunned as Ex-FBI Agent Reveals ‘Porch Guy’ Breakthrough in Nancy Guthrie Investigation

Authorities could be nearing an arrest of the masked, armed “porch guy”…
Former SLED investigator who testified at Alex Murdaugh trial fired from Charleston County Sheriff's Office

Former SLED Investigator Who Testified in Alex Murdaugh Trial Fired by Charleston County Sheriff’s Office

Ryan Kelly, a former South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) investigator, was…
Senate adopts House-passed Iran resolution in symbolic rebuke of Trump

Senate Passes House-Approved Iran Resolution in Symbolic Rebuke of Trump

Washington — The Senate on Tuesday passed a resolution previously approved by the…
Holdout juror in first Etan Patz trial rips top-court ruling upholding later conviction

Etan Patz Trial Holdout Juror Slams New York High Court Ruling Upholding Conviction

The Manhattan juror who stood alone against convicting Pedro Hernandez in the…
Fiancée sticks by accused serial rapist as special agents defend tailing him for restaurant DNA stakeout

Fiancée Stands by Accused Serial Rapist While Agents Defend Restaurant DNA Stakeout

Matthew Nilo, a New Jersey attorney accused of raping or sexually assaulting…
Supreme Court OKs Exxon Mobil lawsuit over Cuban property seized by Fidel Castro's government

Supreme Court Allows Exxon Mobil Lawsuit Over Cuban Property Seized by Castro Government

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that Exxon Mobil may pursue…
Mamdani stumps for far-left House hopefuls as NY primary voters hit the polls

Mamdani Rallies for Far-Left House Candidates as New York Primary Voters Cast Ballots

Mayor Zohran Mamdani spent Tuesday morning crisscrossing New York City to rally…
Marlow: Starmer Ouster Paves Way for Prime Minister Farage -- But It Won't Be an Easy Path

Marlow: Starmer’s Downfall Could Clear a Rocky Road to Prime Minister Nigel Farage

On Monday’s edition of “The Alex Marlow Show,” Editor-in-Chief Alex Marlow turned…
Trump says he'll resurface the bottom of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, turning it blue

Trump Plans to Resurface Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool Bottom in Blue

President Trump’s latest renovation push has extended to one of Washington’s most…
Supreme Court rules Rastafarian ex-inmate can't sue prison officials for shaving dreadlocks

Supreme Court Bars Rastafarian Ex-Inmate’s Lawsuit Over Prison Officials Shaving His Dreadlocks

Washington — The Supreme Court on Tuesday turned away a former Louisiana…