All out, Out East: the most expensive places to stay in the Hamptons

Summer is in full swing, and the polished, sun-soaked world of the Hamptons is once again beckoning.

Over the last 75 years, the string of seaside villages and hamlets on Long Island’s East End has evolved from a quaint haven for artists into a glossy playground for the wealthy, complete with luxury stays to suit its increasingly rarefied reputation.

Today, it’s a marquee summer address for the well-connected, where buzzy bars with New York City pedigrees — Dante among them — sit alongside hotels with eye-watering nightly rates.

With longtime favorites and newly refreshed properties competing for attention, The Post took a look at some of the most expensive places to stay out east — the kind of retreats where affluent guests can relax in style, while everyone else can admire, envy or critique from afar.

The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Roundtree, set conveniently on Main Street in Amagansett, places guests within easy reach of the historic hamlet’s neatly kept charm. Though it is considered an intimate property, the 2-acre, woman-owned, nature-inspired estate delivers luxury on a grand scale.

The boutique hotel caters to upscale travelers seeking a quiet escape from city life, offering a serene collection of countryside-style rooms, suites and private cottages. Accommodations include a “reimagined” barn, a two-bedroom main house and a four-bedroom beach house — the latter once owned by “Barefoot in the Park” playwright Neil Simon.

Guests hoping for an effortless summer getaway at The Roundtree should expect to pay anywhere from $1,495 to $4,395 per night.

Steep as the rates may be, the perks help soften the blow, including the hotel’s well-known continental breakfast spread delivered each morning and beach cruisers available whenever guests are ready to head for the sand.

The lauded guest services team is also on hand and bended knee to arrange private walking tours of LongHouse Reserve, vineyard tastings, fishing excursions or clambake dinners. 

Topping Rose House, Brigehampton

Set in a renovated 19th-century mansion, Brigehampton’s Topping Rose House is a 22-room luxury compound set on two acres of former farmland.

A room at this fancy abode, which is known for its on-site farm-to-table restaurant headed by Chef Jean-Georges, where $38 will buy you a head of cauliflower, a stunning one-acre organic garden, and historic charm, will cost you anywhere between $976 and $4,395 per night.

After dining at the elegant eatery, guests can check out the property’s impressive, rotating contemporary art collection, curated by Winston Wächter Fine Art, before posing for aesthetically pleasing selfies outside by the hotel’s stunning hydrangeas.

Beaches are accessible via a luxury car shuttle.

The Hedges Inn, East Hampton

The recent recipient of what Vanity Fair called “the best facelift in the Hamptons,” the historic Hedges Inn in East Hampton, was redesigned by designer David Netto, who speculated that the update was “going to get a lot of people laid.”

Given the cost of an overnight stay, anywhere between $799 and $3,499 a night, let’s hope so, Dave.

The interiors of the 12-room inn evoke the feeling of staying in your rich friend’s summer home, if your rich friend happened to be the son of Ralph Lauren and Miss Havisham born out of wedlock,

Guests can opt in to a signature beach butler experience at nearby Main Beach, a pink-drenched day on the sand that includes transportation, setup, and refreshments. Breakfast is blessedly included.

EHP Resort, East Hampton

For those with deep pockets, the EHP Resort offers both luxury and seclusion on a large swath of Three Mile Harbor Marina for $797 to $4,900 per night.

The vibe here is Mediterranean minimalist with top notes of Italophile, expressed in the Frette linens for bedding down and Acqua di Parma bath products for basting.

Really leaning into the Dolce Vita ethos, EHP Resort graciously offers daily, complimentary boat rides aboard their 40’ Van Dutch motoryacht and free electric bike rentals.

In an unexpected mix, dogs are welcome, smoking is forbidden, sunset views are unparalleled, and there’s reggae music every Sunday.

Montauk Yacht Club, Montauk

Perfect for those who prefer to travel by yacht over plebeian modes of transport like jitneys or flights, the Montauk Yacht Club, located on the Montauk peninsula, offers understated elegance with a nightly rate of $1,016 to $2,242, equivalent to a midwestern monthly mortgage.

First opened in 1929, when the club counted the Astors, Whitneys, and Vanderbilts among its members, the resort underwent a major overhaul in 2024.

Highlights of the 35-acre property include the floating Cabana Spa, located inside a docked boat on Lake Montauk and featuring luxe ELEMIS treatments and “body rituals.”

Sustainability is a cornerstone here, where harbor cruises are run on electric X Shore boats, AKA the “Teslas of the water.”

Appealing to a young-ish, cerebral but dancey, healthy but hedonistic clientele, resort bait includes reformer Pilates classes, pickleball, nightly DJ sets, backgammon tournaments, and sunset s’mores.

The Faraway, Sag Harbor

Dubbed “the only place we’d recommend staying in Sag Harbor” by the famously highfalutin, chickpea-worshipping folks at Goop, the Faraway Sag Harbor is a recently opened resurrection of the old Baron’s Cove.

The Faraway is the latest addition to the hotel brand, whose properties include hotels in equally pop-collared and top-dollared Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard.

The hotel, which charges $952 to $2,420 per night, is home to Zagara, an Amalfi-inspired restaurant helmed by chef Jarad McCarroll (formerly of the Ritz in London and Hotel Le Toiny in St. Barts). 

The lobby of the 67-room boutique hotel is laden with the scent of the hotel’s signature Maison 21G fragrance, presumably wafting notes of tartar sauce, insider trading, salt spray, and Aperol-stained seersucker.

Staff is fully appointed in Alex Mill, and the lobby and bar have a luxe “under the sea” aesthetic – think seashell bar stools, tentacle handles, and framed nautical prints, part Captain Ahab, part Ariel if she went to Brown.

The feel persists in the on-site speakasy dubbed “Pearl’s Room,” named for a fictional oyster diver, Mother Pearl, because the rich, especially the rich products of divorce, must have their whimsy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

'Today' suspect caught on camera before hate crime arrest, rap sheet reveals attempted kidnapping conviction

Today Show Suspect Filmed Before Hate Crime Arrest Had Attempted Kidnapping Conviction, Records Show

The man charged in an alleged hate crime involving “Today” co-host Craig…
Grandpa tossed 8 feet into air by Yellowstone bison speaks of ordeal from his hospital bed

Grandfather Thrown 8 Feet in Yellowstone Bison Attack Recounts Ordeal From Hospital Bed

A grandfather hurled eight feet into the air by a charging bison…
Florida man arrested in IHOP restaurant after police say he stabbed an rideshare driver

Florida Man Arrested at IHOP After Allegedly Stabbing Rideshare Driver

A Florida man was taken into custody Monday inside an Orlando IHOP…
Nicaragua's Ortega says country will 'never again' hold elections, shutting out opposition

Ortega Says Nicaragua Will End Elections, Shut Out Rivals

Wall Street eyes the midterm election map Libby Cantrill, Pimco’s head of…
Darline Graham, Lindsey Graham's sister, says she'll run for full Senate term

Darline Graham, Sister of Lindsey Graham, Announces Run for Full Senate Term

Washington — Sen. Darline Graham, appointed to complete the late Sen. Lindsey…
Gas prices top $4 a gallon as Iran war escalates

Gas Prices Surge Past $4 a Gallon as Iran War Escalates

The national average for U.S. gas prices climbed above $4 a gallon…
Congress to put American Bar Association in hot seat over DEI rules tied to law school accreditation

Congress Targets ABA’s DEI Rules for Law School Accreditation

Congress is preparing to scrutinize the American Bar Association’s powerful role in…
Road rage driver who allegedly killed boxing star Hannah Rapp is career criminal with lengthy rap sheet

Hannah Rapp Road Rage Death: Accused Driver Had Lengthy Criminal Record

The motorist accused of killing rising boxing talent Hannah Rapp in an…
SFPD officer Mike Petuya strikes homeless man with car

SFPD Officer Mike Petuya Hits Homeless Man With Car

A man experiencing homelessness in San Francisco remained in critical condition Monday…
Europe's 'green ideology' climate agenda risks crushing its industry, environment minister warns

Green Ideology Could Crush Europe’s Industry, Minister Warns

UNITED NATIONS — Europe could put its industrial future at risk if…
Feds slam Hochul push for NY solar farms: 'On-brand elitism' 

Federal Officials Blast Gov. Hochul’s New York Solar Farm Push as ‘On-Brand Elitism’

Gov. Kathy Hochul’s push to expand large-scale solar projects across rural upstate…
Utah hiker killed by lightning just steps from mountain summit during trek with brother

Utah Hiker Killed by Lightning Near Mountain Summit While Trekking With Brother

A Utah hiker died last week after being struck by lightning while…