Yankees' hopes for ALDS comeback now revolve around Carlos Rodon

Since Carlos Rodón joined the Yankees, Andy Pettitte has guided his fellow left-hander through a sometimes rocky first three seasons. 

In Game 3, the Yankees hope for Rodón to emulate Pettitte’s successful postseason performances to salvage their season, as they trail 2-0 to Toronto in the best-of-five ALDS at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday night.

“It all starts with Carlos on the mound,” Pettitte said Monday before a light Yankee workout in The Bronx. “We all know games like this hinge on pitching. Sure, we need to score runs, but it begins with Carlos.”

Rodón was in a similar spot in the wild-card round against Boston after the Yankees dropped the first game of that series.

Though he wasn’t at his peak, Rodón positioned the Yankees to win that crucial game, which allowed them to advance in three games.

They face even more of a challenge now, needing three straight wins to get by the Blue Jays and into the ALCS. 

“I think he’s ready,” Pettitte noted. “He experienced something similar recently and performed excellently; he’s been here before. In these games, you try to simplify, manage your emotions, and make key pitches. It’s like any other game, but you know the stakes.”


Carlos Rodon pitches during the Yankees-Red Sox game on Oct. 1, 2025.
Carlos Rodon pitches during the Yankees-Red Sox game on Oct. 1, 2025. Charles Wenzelberg / New York Post

Rodón has been inconsistent in the playoffs as a Yankee, with a 5.32 ERA over 23 ²/₃ innings in five playoff starts.

The Yankees have won three of those games. 



However, following back-to-back tough starts from Luis Gil in Game 1 and Max Fried in Game 2 at Rogers Centre, they need significantly more from Rodón, who’s pitched at least five innings and allowed three or fewer runs in 11 consecutive starts — including against Boston.

That’s why Aaron Boone said he had “a ton” of confidence in Rodón heading into Tuesday. 

“He’s obviously been one of our mainstays this year,” Boone said. “He’s had a fantastic year, and whenever he’s on the mound, we feel confident in our chances to win. That sentiment holds true [Tuesday].”

Rodón was OK in a pair of starts against the Blue Jays this season — pitching to a 3.60 ERA in 10 innings with both starts coming in Toronto — but Vlad Guerrero Jr., who killed the Yankees in the first two games of this series, has been a menace against Rodón, going 10-for-17 with three doubles and a homer. 

Still, his teammates know he won’t back down from the challenge. 


New York Yankees pitcher Carlos Rodón throws during batting practice.
Yankees pitcher Carlos Rodón throws during batting practice before Game 1 of the ALDS. JASON SZENES/ NY POST

“Every time he’s on the mound, full confidence in him,’’ Cody Bellinger said. “I just love who he is as a competitor.”

You May Also Like

‘Santa Clarita Karen’ forced to apologize as her business implodes

Santa Clarita Woman Apologizes as Business Faces Backlash

A California business owner known online as “Santa Clarita Karen” is speaking…
Assemblywoman Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn won't seek another term as Brooklyn Democratic Party chair

Brooklyn Democratic Chair Bichotte Hermelyn Won’t Run Again

New York Assemblywoman Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn announced Monday night that she will…
White House reporters share shocking choices on which Republicans could run for president after Trump

White House Reporters Reveal Surprise Republicans to Run After Trump

AUSTIN, Texas — Three high-profile White House journalists offered an early look…
At least 40 rescued, 2 dead as boat capsizes after machete fight near Puerto Rico

2 Dead, 40 Rescued After Machete Fight Capsizes Boat Off Puerto Rico

At least 40 people were pulled from the ocean by the U.S.…
Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing

Lindsay Clancy Bid to Probe Holdout Juror Hits Snag Ahead of Retrial

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — A Massachusetts judge is expected to hear arguments Tuesday…
US visa clash exposes Sudan’s forgotten war as foreign powers compete for strategic foothold

US Visa Clash Puts Sudan’s Forgotten War, Foreign Rivalry in Focus

Sudan’s military leader is rejecting a U.S.-backed push for a ceasefire after…
NYT exec killed by in-laws threatened wife's life, court docs say

Court Docs: NYT Executive Killed by In-Laws Threatened Wife’s Life

Jonathan McKinsey, a transgender New York Times executive who was allegedly shot…
Kentucky trooper, father of 3, gunned down during traffic stop as suspect captured after manhunt

Kentucky Trooper, Dad of 3, Killed in Traffic Stop; Suspect Captured

A routine traffic stop on a Kentucky interstate ended in tragedy Monday…
Clancy holdout juror taps former Trump lawyer to fight back as he’s ‘dragged through the mud’: attorney

Lindsay Clancy’s Juror Inquiry May Pause as Both Sides Seek Delay

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Lindsay Clancy’s defense team and Massachusetts prosecutors have agreed…
Slain NYT exec was transgender targeted by in-law: docs

Court Docs: In-Law Targeted Slain NYT Exec Over Transgender Status

A New York Times technology executive who was allegedly shot and killed…
Navy military device washed up on California beach and taken to home

Navy Military Device Washes Ashore on California Beach, Taken Home by Beachgoer

A military device capable of burning at temperatures as high as 3,000…
Mexico's Baja California braces for major Hurricane Polo as Hurricane Nolo still threatens Hawaii

Baja California Braces for Hurricane Polo as Hurricane Nolo Continues to Threaten Hawaii

Residents across Mexico’s Baja California Sur sealed up their homes Monday as…