Share this @internewscast.com

Some fertility clinics and shipping services plan to hold off on sending frozen embryos from Alabama to other states as they weigh the legal implications of an Alabama court ruling that says embryos created through in vitro fertilization are children.

Many doctors and patients are confused about which elements of fertility treatment are restricted, following the Alabama Supreme Court decision last week, and at least three Alabama providers have paused IVF services. Some IVF patients have considered moving their embryos out of the state to continue the process elsewhere, only to learn that the option isn’t available to them right now.

RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association announced Friday that nationwide embryo shipping services have indicated that they will stop transporting embryos to and from Alabama.

“This slight window of hope for Alabamans currently undergoing IVF to continue their family-building treatment in other states just slammed shut,” RESOLVE CEO Barbara Collura said in a statement.

At least two IVF providers in Alabama told NBC News they have paused shipping of embryos, as well.

The University of Alabama at Birmingham, which suspended IVF services this week, said Thursday that it is not sending embryos to new locations for now.

“We understand some patients wish to transport their embryos to another facility,” UAB said in a statement. “Companies that transport embryos are also assessing the risks associated with the Alabama Supreme Court ruling, and we are working to identify a company that is able and willing as soon as possible. It is our goal to help patients who are interested in this option do so safely, but — at this time — there are no options available.”

Meghan Cole, a patient at Alabama Fertility in Birmingham, was expecting her embryo to be implanted in a surrogate Friday (Cole has a blood disorder that prevents her from safely carrying a pregnancy). But the appointment was canceled Wednesday night after the clinic decided to pause IVF services.

She inquired about transferring her embryos to an out-of-state facility, but a doctor told her that the practice was worried it would be liable for any potential damage to the embryos during transit, she said.

“Now, even if I wanted to get them out of the state and do a transfer in another state or where my surrogate lives, I can’t,” Cole said. “I’m just kind of stuck until something changes down here, which who knows how long that’s going to take?”

Alabama Fertility did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

Dr. Brett Davenport, a reproductive endocrinologist at Fertility Institute of North Alabama, said that even though his practice is continuing IVF services, it isn’t shipping embryos, either.

“I’m not actively destroying embryos, nor am I transporting embryos out of state, just because I think that this is very possibly going to be resolved in about a month,” he said.

The Alabama court found that people can be held legally responsible for the destruction of embryos under the state’s Wrongful Death Act, which says that an unjustified or negligent act that leads to someone’s death is a civil offense. So providers of IVF services and embryo transport now fear legal repercussions if embryos are discarded — a common part of the IVF process, since some embryos can have genetic abnormalities or may no longer be needed.

However, the Alabama Supreme Court’s Feb. 16 ruling applied to a unique circumstance: Three couples sued a fertility clinic in Mobile, Alabama, after a person wandered into an unlocked storage area and dropped frozen embryos on the floor. The court ruled that because an embryo is considered a person, the clinic’s failure to secure that storage area violated the state’s Wrongful Death Act.

Legal experts are hesitant to speculate on the broader implications.

“Parents of an embryo that is destroyed can sue the person who destroyed the embryo for wrongful death — that’s all this decision said. We’ll have to wait and see what may play out later on in the courts if there are subsequent lawsuits seeking to weaponize this opinion to ban IVF,” said Gail Deady, senior staff attorney at the Center for Reproductive Rights.

The Alabama Legislature could also act to protect IVF. Five Democrats introduced a bill in the Alabama House of Representatives on Thursday that stipulates that embryos outside of a uterus are neither unborn children nor human beings under state law. Republican state Sen. Tim Melson also announced Thursday that he plans to introduce a similar bill clarifying that embryos aren’t human lives until they’re implanted in the uterus.

It’s not clear when fertility clinics might feel comfortable enough to resume normal operations — or whether patients who intended to discard embryos will have to continue paying storage fees in the interim. Storing frozen embryos can cost $350 to $1,000 per year.

Cole said she’s sympathetic to her clinic’s position, but she’s also worried about the potential for spiraling implications of the Alabama ruling.

“The clinic is afraid to even release the embryos to us for transfer to another state. I’m like, ‘Well, theoretically, aren’t you kidnapping my children?’” she said. “How far are we taking this? Can I claim them as dependents on my tax return?”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
White House ballroom lawsuit: National Trust says it won't drop suit after DOJ request's amid Correspondents' Dinner shooting

National Trust Stands Firm: Lawsuit Over White House Ballroom Continues Despite DOJ’s Plea Following Correspondents’ Dinner Incident

WASHINGTON — Advocates for historic preservation are moving forward with their legal…
Stunning hot mic moment captures TV host ripping security at WHCD before shooting: 'Two random chicks'

TV Host’s Candid Comments on Security at WHCD Caught on Hot Mic Before Filming: ‘Two Random Individuals

During the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, Fox News host Jimmy Failla was…
Rep. Ilhan Omar mocked over brutal World War ‘11’ gaffe in resurfaced video

Resurfaced Video Reveals Rep. Ilhan Omar’s World War ’11’ Gaffe, Sparking Online Reactions

Social media erupted with mockery on Monday following the resurfacing of a…
LA's 911 system on brink of collapse as it operates below capacity

LA’s 911 Crisis: Understaffed System Struggles to Keep Up with Demand

Los Angeles first responders are grappling with delays in handling 911 calls…
Brooklyn attack leaves 3 injured, suspect wearing Iranian flag shirt arrested by NYPD

Brooklyn Incident: Three Injured, Suspect in Iranian Flag Shirt Apprehended by NYPD

A man in New York City, reportedly wearing a shirt featuring the…
Cold case cracked after 40 years as teen's alleged killers are caught after podcast helps find new leads

Podcast Investigation Leads to Arrests in 40-Year-Old Cold Case Murder of Teen

In a remarkable turn of events, four men in Louisiana have been…
White House ballroom lawsuit: National Trust says it won't drop suit after DOJ request's amid Correspondents' Dinner shooting

National Trust Defies DOJ: White House Ballroom Lawsuit Stands Firm Amid Correspondents’ Dinner Turmoil

Preservationists are forging ahead with their legal challenge against President Donald Trump’s…
Unabomber investigator reveals likely breaking point of alleged would-be Trump assassin

Unabomber Investigator Uncovers Potential Trigger in Alleged Plot Against Trump

A veteran FBI criminal profiler, who played a key role in the…
Unabomber investigator reveals likely breaking point of alleged would-be Trump assassin

Unveiled: The Critical Moment That Drove Alleged Trump Assassin Over the Edge, According to DC Sniper Investigator

TORRANCE, Calif. — A former FBI criminal profiler has weighed in on…
Katie Porter's vile two-word insult targeting Trump sparks outrage after assassination attempt

Katie Porter’s Shocking Insult to Trump Ignites Controversy Amid Assassination Attempt Drama

A fundraising email for California gubernatorial hopeful Katie Porter has sparked controversy…
Woman falls to her death on Carnival cruise near Catalina Island

Tragic Incident as Woman Fatally Falls on Carnival Cruise Near Catalina Island

A tragic incident occurred aboard a Carnival cruise ship when a woman…
Three-year-old girl killed, pregnant mother injured after alleged drag racers split car in half in Arizona

ICE Announces Arrest of Predators and Kidnappers in Weekend Crackdown

On Monday, the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) unveiled its latest…