Florida Man Sentenced for Killing, Dismembering, and Burning Dating App Girlfriend

A Florida court handed down a life sentence on Wednesday to a man who murdered a woman he connected with on a dating app, driven by anger over her not adhering to his “relationship rules.”

Daniel Stearns, 35, was found guilty earlier this month, according to WESH.

His arrest came in March 2023 after law enforcement tracked his movements to an undeveloped area in Palm Bay, known as “The Compound.” There, authorities discovered the remains of 44-year-old Nancy Howery, as detailed by CrimeOnline.

Howery, who was a mother to two young children, was reported missing on February 18 after she didn’t show up to collect her kids from school. Her vehicle was subsequently found deserted.

According to Stearns’ arrest warrant, tensions had been escalating between him and Howery in the days leading up to her disappearance. Police surveillance captured Stearns traveling from his residence to The Compound.

The warrant further revealed that law enforcement suspects Stearns fatally shot Howery during a dispute on February 15, subsequently dismembering and incinerating her body. Her remains were uncovered in at least five separate locations within the sprawling 12-square-mile area known as The Compound.

At the sentencing hearing on Wednesday, prosecutor Samantha Barrett told the judge that Stearns “was angry at Ms. Howery,” Law& Crime reported.

“He was jealous, because she was seeing other men and that their relationship was not exclusive,” the prosecutor said. “She was not, to quote him, ‘following his relationship rules.’”

Howery’s ex-husband, Todd Howery, also spoke at the hearing.

“What he has done to Nancy was demented and defective,” he said. ” … It wasn’t just a murder, okay? It was a savage slaughter.”

Stearns was sentenced to life in prison for murder and more than 22 years extra for abuse of a corpse and tampering with evidence.

You May Also Like

‘Unlawfully Fired’ Mar-a-Lago FBI Agents Ask Judge Cannon for Clarity

Main: An aerial view of former President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago club in…

Husband Who Ran Over Wife After She Jumped From Truck May Face Prison

Insets: Jeremy Micheal Davidson (Sibley County Jail via KEYC) and Melissa Davidson…

Mother Accused of Plotting to Kill Daughter’s Boyfriend Over Alleged Drug Addiction Takes Plea Deal

Inset: Wendy Coe (Park County Sheriff). Background: Park County Courthouse in Cody,…

Gainesville Woman Arrested for Puncturing Boyfriend With Nail Board

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Sierra Skye Fararo-Curran, 34, was arrested early…

Man Sentenced for Fatally Shooting McDonald’s Worker at Drive-Thru

Inset: Ja’Quan Dontremique Green (Prince George’s County Police). Background: The McDonald’s where…

American Idol Murder Trial: OH v. Caleb Flynn

The American Idol Murder Trial – OH v. Caleb Flynn is underway…

Sword-Wielding Man Arrested in Armed Burglary Assault Case

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Josiah D-ante Lee Smith, 26, was arrested…

Lawsuit: Trump Threats to Send ICE, FBI to Polls Violate VRA

President Donald Trump listens during a Cabinet meeting Friday, July 31, 2026,…

Woman Says She Hit No One After 125-MPH Chase Hurts Trooper

Inset left: Martell Tolbert Mitchell (Dunn County Sheriff’s Office). Inset right: Trooper…

Who Is Tomasz Kosowski? Surgeon Guilty in Cozzi Murder

Tomasz Kosowski is a former Florida plastic surgeon who was found guilty…