Columbia University can continue keeping its gates closed to the public after a Manhattan judge rejected a lawsuit seeking to reopen a once-public path through the Ivy League campus.
The case was brought by Morningside Heights residents who argued that the university should restore access to College Walk. Although the lawsuit has been dismissed, the residents say they intend to continue fighting.
“My clients and I are very disappointed in today’s decision, and plan to appeal,” attorney Toby Golick said, according to the New York Daily News.
Filed last year, the lawsuit was dismissed last week after Judge David Cohen ruled that the residents have “no right” to access College Walk.
The route runs across West 116th Street between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue. For years, it served as a convenient passageway for Columbia students as well as members of the public traveling through the neighborhood.
Columbia closed the gates to the public following protests in October 2023. The campus remained restricted during the spring of 2024, when anti-Israel protesters established encampments on the university’s lawns, prompting police intervention.
The restrictions have remained in place ever since. Students and faculty members now need Columbia-issued identification to enter, while security guards continue to monitor the locked gates.
SEE ALSO: Australians Pay Fortunes Overseas for Needle-Free Cancer Treatment
In their lawsuit, the residents cited a 1953 agreement under which New York City transferred that section of West 116th Street to the university. They argued that the deal required College Walk to remain accessible to the public.
The residents also claimed that keeping the gates closed violates disability protections because older and disabled neighbors are forced to take lengthy detours around the campus.
Judge Cohen rejected those arguments, finding no language in the 1953 agreement that established a public right to use the walkway.
“Even if Columbia previously granted unrestricted public access to College Walk, as it remained their private property, nothing prevented them from restricting access at any time,” the ruling states.
The decision follows a September warning from Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who grew up in the neighborhood and is the son of a Columbia professor. Mamdani had threatened legal action if the university did not reopen its gates.
A Columbia spokesperson said the university “very much” welcomed the court’s recognition that College Walk is private property, according to a statement provided to the Columbia Daily Spectator.