ABC asks federal judge to block FCC's early license review, citing retaliation by Trump administration

Disney’s ABC asked a federal judge Tuesday to halt an early review of the network’s broadcast licenses, arguing that the Federal Communications Commission launched the proceeding to punish ABC for programming that angered the Trump administration.

At a roughly two-hour hearing in federal court in Washington, D.C., ABC attorneys pointed to remarks by President Trump and FCC Chair Brendan Carr as evidence of the agency’s alleged motive. They said those statements showed why the FCC took the unprecedented step in April of ordering eight ABC-owned stations to file broadcast-license renewal applications years earlier than required.

The licenses had originally been scheduled for renewal between 2028 and 2031.

“They are retaliating with their government power to stop ABC from exercising their protected First Amendment speech,” Beth Wilkinson, an attorney for the company, told the court.

At one point, Wilkinson invoked the French Revolution to describe the FCC’s actions. She said the agency was effectively making the broadcaster wait with its “head on a guillotine” as it seeks a decision on the licenses.

Wilkinson argued that the process is already having a chilling effect on ABC’s editorial choices. She said some programming decisions could ultimately prompt the FCC to “give us the corporate death penalty and take away our licenses.”

She also cited a speech Mr. Trump delivered at the White House in July, when he criticized ABC and NBC for declining to broadcast it and called for their licenses to be revoked. Wilkinson described those comments as a “direct threat” to ABC.

“People may not like some of ABC’s coverage and the president is entitled to it, but the public has the right to be exposed to different speech and viewpoints,” she said.

The Justice Department, which is defending the FCC, maintains that the agency’s April decision was prompted by Disney’s failure to adequately answer an ongoing investigation into its diversity, equity and inclusion practices.

ABC “refused to adequately respond” to the FCC’s anti-discrimination inquiry, said Dimitar Georgiev-Remme, a Justice Department attorney representing the commission. “The commission decided to look for information that it needed by calling for early renewal of plaintiffs’ broadcast license.”

Much of Tuesday’s hearing focused on whether Disney and ABC have the legal right to challenge the FCC’s early-renewal process in federal district court.

The Justice Department argues that federal law requires a company to challenge a license-renewal order first before the full FCC. Any unfavorable decision would then have to be reviewed by a federal appeals court, rather than a U.S. district court, the government said.

ABC contends that the alleged retaliation falls outside the regulatory appeals system established by Congress. The company says a district court challenge is the only available way to address the immediate harm caused by the FCC’s action.

As an example, Wilkinson said ABC has altered how it covers political issues. She specifically noted that the talk show “The View” has changed the way it chooses clips for broadcast.

She also said comedian Jimmy Kimmel, a longtime Trump critic, posted his interview with Democratic Texas Senate candidate James Talarico on YouTube instead of airing it on the network.

Wilkinson argued that even if ABC had appealed the FCC’s April decision to begin the early renewal process, the commission could delay action indefinitely.

She added that ABC would have no meaningful legal remedy for the damage it says it has suffered if the FCC ultimately renews the licenses after completing its review.

U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan, a Biden appointee, at times appeared unconvinced by the government’s argument that the FCC began the early renewal process simply to obtain information for its anti-discrimination investigation.

When AliKhan asked what other legal tools the Justice Department could use to compel ABC to provide the requested information, Georgiev-Remme was unable to offer an immediate answer. The judge then ordered the government to file a brief addressing the question by Oct. 9.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

FBI arrests Georgia man accused of sending cryptocurrency to ISIS-linked individuals and groups

FBI Arrests Georgia Man Over Crypto Sent to ISIS-Linked Groups

A Georgia man has been charged federally with allegedly funneling more than…
Student assaulted in dorm at $100K-a-year college, police hunt for suspect: report

Police Search for Suspect After Dorm Assault at $100K-a-Year College

NYU student allegedly raped in dorm as police search for suspect Authorities…
Nvidia says it will stop selling some AI data center chips to China

Nvidia to Stop Selling Some AI Data Center Chips to China

Nvidia interim CEO Colette Kress said Tuesday that the company has halted…
Famous California farmers died of carbon monoxide poisoning, toxicology shows

California Farming Family Died of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning, Toxicology Confirms

A prominent California farming couple who died after attending a party at…
Under-fire DHS boss Markwayne Mullin sidelined by White House after disastrous TV interviews, college football trip

Oklahoma Sen. Markwayne Mullin Sidelined After TV Interview Fallout

WASHINGTON — Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has been pulled back from…
Woman runs 7 marathons while pregnant this year:

Woman Completes 7 Marathons While Pregnant This Year

Deirdre Keane had completed more than 60 marathons when she decided to…
Teen accused of fatally shooting identical twin brother after fight about touching his belongings

Teen Charged With Fatally Shooting Identical Twin Brother After Dispute Over Belongings

A 16-year-old boy was arrested Wednesday in connection with the fatal shooting…
Stony Brook-bound QB leads Ward Melville to Suffolk championship

Stony Brook-Bound Quarterback Leads Ward Melville to Suffolk Title

Hudson Philbrick has transformed the Ward Melville Patriots into a force to…
Susan Smith prosecutor fears her release would put her in grieving father’s face ‘every day’

Susan Smith Prosecutor Fears Release Would Haunt Grieving Father

The prosecutor who helped send Susan Smith to prison says he worries…
South Carolina duo charged in road rage murder of Scott Spivey

Two South Carolina Men Charged in Road Rage Killing of Scott Spivey

Two South Carolina men have been charged with murder in the road-rage…
MICHAEL RUIZ: What is a dirty bomb? Explosive terror threat explained

What Is a Dirty Bomb? Explosive Terror Threat Explained

No dirty bomb is known to have been successfully used in a…
Ravaging storms could impact Thanksgiving travel as East Coast slated with extreme rain, snow

Severe East Coast Storms Threaten Thanksgiving Travel Plans

Thanksgiving travel season is nearly here, and millions of Americans are preparing…