CHICAGO (WLS) — The ABC7 I-Team is issuing a cautionary message for those who rely on rideshare services for transportation.
Many might be unaware that in the event of an accident during a rideshare journey, they may have unknowingly forfeited their right to a jury trial against the rideshare company.
Instead of a courtroom battle, injured riders often find themselves navigating arbitration. This process places the decision in the hands of a single arbitrator rather than a jury, potentially leading to significantly different compensation outcomes.
A local lawyer alongside his client is sounding the alarm.
ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch
In late 2025, Jaleigh Nelson was using Lyft to head to her job near the bustling “Six Corners” in Portage Park when an accident occurred.
“It was terrifying; I was disoriented and uncertain about the situation,” Nelson recounted. “I was in considerable pain, overwhelmed with anxiety, and shaken.”
Nelson was in the back seat of a Lyft, when the car was t-boned by another car. The police report said her Lyft driver “failed to yield and merged into his causing the accident.” The Lyft driver was cited.
“I wish he was more cautious,” Nelson said.
Nelson was able to snap a photo before being taken to a nearby hospital with minor injuries.
“I was angry… Taken me out of work for a month and a couple weeks,” Nelson said.
Aside from the financial losses from not working, she says she also suffered a neck injury and is in physical therapy for her right shoulder and elbow. A lawsuit against the individual driver lists her injuries, but she may not be able to sue the company, Lyft in court. That’s because consumers on rideshare apps like Lyft, Uber, and Curb agree to these “terms and conditions” when signing up.
The clauses say you waive your right to a jury trial and must pursue a claim through to arbitration.
Michael Sorich/ Cavanagh Sorich Law Group Sorich 00;02;10;42
“The difference between going to an arbitration as opposed to having a jury trial is you don’t have 12 citizens from your county deciding your case,” said Michael Sorich with Cavanagh Sorich Law Group. “We want our cases to be heard by jury trials and jurors deciding the facts, as opposed to some corporate arbitrator picking a number out of thin air.”
Nelson’s attorney, Sorich, says juries usually pay more. He says his law firm has found ways around the arbitration clauses and is trying to do the same with Nelson. But not all lawyers may be able to do so. Others are also challenging the process. The Illinois Supreme Court is currently deciding if a local Uber wrongful death case will go through arbitration, or if it can be argued in court.
If you’re in a crash and are able, document everything you can.
“You want to take photos, you want to take videos, you want to document that scene, because undoubtedly the rideshare company will have investigators looking into this matter early on, as should the injured party,” Sorich said.
The I-Team reached out to all three apps about the arbitration clauses.
Uber pointed to its “comprehensive insurance coverage” for drivers while working and pointed out that both parties must agree on an arbitrator. If they can’t agree, a court will select one.
Both Uber and Lyft said arbitration agreements are common practice across various industries. And Lyft added that they are “in accordance with the Federal Arbitration Act. The arbitration process gives participants a hearing before a neutral third party, often in a fraction of the time litigation takes, and can offer a more accessible way for parties to resolve disputes.”
Lyft did not comment specifically on Nelson’s case.
2 shot Nelson on arbitration 26:46
“It’s not fair for that person who was hit,” Nelson said.
The Curb app has not yet gotten back to the I-Team.
Despite the arbitration rules, riders may still be able to file in small claims court, or they can still sue the individual driver on the rideshare platform.
As mentioned, Nelson’s attorneys are doing that. The driver did not return ABC7’s calls for comment.
The driver responded to that lawsuit, saying he denies any allegations of wrongdoing.
More information:
Uber arbitration clause
Lyft clause
Curb
Copyright © 2026 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.
