The Yankees greats who didn’t make the cut

You’re familiar with the debate: Who belongs on your Mount Rushmore of… anything. Be it athletes, singers, actors, or presidents (even though there’s an actual one for presidents, your personal choice still counts). 

Now The Post is getting in the mix — with our Mount Postmores. 

We’ve put together expert panels of our writers and editors to decide which four individuals deserve recognition for each of our local teams, across all sports, and — naturally — a definitive New York foursome to represent the rich tapestry of our city’s storied sports history. 

We’re excited to reveal our selections on Post Sports+. 

We also want to hear from you. Join us over the next two weeks not only to see our selections but to share yours on our digital and social media platforms. 


It is the debate that has filled countless hours at bars, family rooms or stadiums: Who are the greatest Yankees of all-time? 

Mount Postmore tabbed Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Lou Gehrig and Joe DiMaggio.

Hard to argue with, but there are certainly cases to be made for a few others who have done plenty of winning during their careers in pinstripes. Here are the three who received votes from our panel: 

Yogi Berra 

In an organization steeped in championships, no one has won more than Berra (10). 


Black and white photo of Yogi Berra catching a baseball.
Yogi Berra of the New York Yankees grabbing for a foul pop during a 1962 game. AP

The three-time MVP was a career .285 hitter with a .830 OPS while going down as one of the game’s best catchers of all-time. 

Berra was also famous for his Yogisms that still get quoted to this day, most notably, “It ain’t over till it’s over.” 

Derek Jeter 

This generation’s greatest Yankee, the Captain was at the heart of the Yankees’ 1990s dynasty that still is the last MLB team to win back-to-back World Series titles — never mind the three straight they won from 1998-2000. 

Jeter, who became Mr. November with his memorable home run in Game 4 of the 2001 World Series, finished his career with 3,465 hits and five Gold Gloves.

A generation of kids, like current Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe, grew up trying to make the Jeter play in the hole. 

A five-time World Series champion, Jeter hit .308 in a record 158 playoff games 


Derek Jeter of the New York Yankees at bat.
Derek Jeter swings through on a single surpassing Yogi Berra with 2,149 hits on Sept. 30, 2006. JASON SZENES for the NEW YORK PO

Mariano Rivera 

Part of the Core Four with Jeter, Rivera notched 42 saves and a 0.70 ERA in 96 career playoff appearances to help secure five World Series championships. 

The first player ever to be unanimously inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, Rivera finished with 652 career saves, a mark that might never be broken.

Armed with a devastating cutter, the right-hander made the ninth inning about as pain-free as any closer in the history of the game. 

You May Also Like

Lawsuit says Anthropic, OpenAI, SpaceXAI and Google made illegal agreement on AI development slowdown

Lawsuit Alleges Anthropic, OpenAI, SpaceXAI and Google Made Illegal AI Development Slowdown Pact

Anthropic, OpenAI, SpaceXAI and Google are accused in a new lawsuit of…
Massive fire rips through NYC restaurant, injuring 6 firefighters

NYC Restaurant Fire Injures 6 Firefighters During Response

A four-alarm fire ripped through a Brooklyn commercial building housing three restaurants…
Hundreds of dead chickens found abandoned in NYC U-Hauls: cops and activists

Hundreds of Dead Chickens Found in Abandoned NYC U-Hauls

Hundreds of chickens abandoned in Brooklyn were facing what animal rights activists…
DOJ charges 16 in illegal voting probe across multiple states

DOJ Charges 16 in Illegal Voting Investigation Spanning States

The Department of Justice has charged 16 people across several states in…
Bronzeville, Chicago crime: Police department investigating 69 car break-ins in parking lots near 33rd and State,

Chicago Police Probe 69 Car Break-Ins in Bronzeville Lots

CHICAGO () — Chicago police are investigating after suspects broke into at…
Detroit family claims funeral home presented another woman's body at viewing

Detroit Family Says Funeral Home Showed Wrong Woman’s Body at Viewing

A Detroit family says a funeral home displayed an unidentified woman wearing…
Michigan city and mayor face civil rights lawsuit

Michigan City and Mayor Sued in Civil Rights Lawsuit

A federal lawsuit filed Thursday claims Dearborn used thousands of taxpayer dollars…
ICE-led Florida operation nets 500 — including illegal aliens accused of murder, child abuse, cartel ties

Florida ICE Sweep Arrests 500, Including Murder Suspects

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement joined more than five federal, state and…
DC man killed newborn, tried framing autistic son, 6, for murder: prosecutors

Prosecutors: DC Man Killed Newborn, Tried to Frame His 6-Year-Old Autistic Son

A Washington, D.C., man allegedly beat his girlfriend’s 2-month-old daughter to death…
Thousands of volunteers hit LA beaches in massive coastal trash cleanup

Thousands Join Massive Coastal Trash Cleanup Across Los Angeles Beaches

Thousands of Los Angeles County residents set aside their usual Saturday routines,…
New Jersey mom charged with obstruction after 'missing' son found hiding in her crawl space

New Jersey Mom Charged After Missing Son Found Hiding in Crawl Space

A New Jersey mother is facing an obstruction charge after her missing…
Tree limb that injured NYC hotdog vendor was just inspected: city

NYC Says Tree Limb That Hurt Hot Dog Vendor Was Recently Inspected

The tree limb that struck a hot dog vendor near the Museum…