Lindsay Clancy's push to probe holdout juror hits snag before pivotal retrial hearing

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — A Massachusetts judge is expected to hear arguments Tuesday on Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss her case on double jeopardy grounds. A separate request to investigate the lone holdout juror from her mistrial may be delayed, at least temporarily.

Clancy is expected to appear in court in person for the first time since her trial ended with a deadlocked jury and the judge declared a mistrial on Sept. 4.

In the weeks following the mistrial, the case has continued to draw national attention. Several jurors and Clancy’s defense attorney have criticized the lone holdout, while the Plymouth County District Attorney’s Office has offered few details about whether it intends to seek a retrial.

Lindsay Clancy listens to testimony in Plymouth Superior Court.

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court last month. (Boston Globe via Getty Images)

Here is what to expect when Clancy returns to court:

Defense calls to investigate the holdout juror

Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, sought an inquiry into Michael Desronvil, the only juror who did not agree with the rest of the panel. Reddington has referred to Desronvil as “the obstructionist juror.” Desronvil opposed the other 11 jurors and remained the only panel member who wanted to convict Clancy.

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy were killed at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

But Edward Paltzik, the attorney representing Desronvil, said Reddington and Plymouth County prosecutors agreed to postpone the motion after he objected. Paltzik said he had not yet received access to impounded materials needed to prepare a response.

“The DA and Reddington consent to adjourn the motion to investigate Michael,” Paltzik told Fox News’ Kayleigh McEnany on Monday.

A man in a plaid shirt sits and cradles a sleeping infant wrapped in a pink blanket.

Michael P. Desronvil was the lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, which ended in a mistrial. (Fugitive TV)

“If Judge Sullivan signs an order today, much of it could be adjourned,” Paltzik said. “Either way, a status conference is still likely.”

Reddington strongly disputed that characterization, while acknowledging that he and the district attorney’s office had agreed to move the motion at the request of the local attorney now representing the juror.

The defense attorney walking into court.

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington speaks to reporters as jurors deliberate in the case involving the 2023 deaths of Lindsay Clancy’s three children. (Photo by JOSEPH PREZIOSO / AFP via Getty Images)

“Earlier today, both the government and I were contacted by a professional local attorney who represents Juror Doe,” Reddington said, avoiding the juror’s name because of a court impoundment order. “That attorney requested — as any qualified counsel would — adequate time to review our motion and reply.”

He continued: “As is professional courtesy, both the government and I agreed to continue this specific motion to a later date at their request. The motion remains active, fully alive, and is currently pending a ruling from Judge Sullivan. We will not allow a publicity-seeking opportunist to twist simple courtroom courtesy into a victory that does not exist.”

Although the terms “adjourned” and “continued” are sometimes used similarly, they have different legal meanings.

“Adjournment generally signifies that something like a hearing is off indefinitely, especially because no date is specified,” explained retired Massachusetts Judge Carol Erskine. “A continuance is a simple request by a party or two parties to get a new date. [Reddington] objects because adjournment is a misrepresentation of what is happening.”

Lindsay Clancy trial

District Attorney Timothy Cruz leaves Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Massachusetts, on Thursday, Sept. 3, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

If Reddington ultimately succeeds, the court could hold a Fidler hearing, during which the judge would question Desronvil.

“There are three phases to a hearing like that,” said Erskine, who is also a child welfare advocate and has closely followed the case. “This is something that could result in a strong manifest necessity claim, but it’s hard to tell until it happens.”

Judge William Sullivan presides as Lindsay Clancy appears in Plymouth Superior Court during jury deliberations

Judge William Sullivan, left, delivered a rare Tuey-Rodriguez charge to the deadlocked jury as Lindsay Clancy, right, looked on during proceedings in Plymouth Superior Court. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via Pool and David L. Ryan/Pool)

Manifest necessity is the legal standard required to hold a second trial. Erskine said the motion is a long-shot but Reddington is likely laying the foundation for an appeal in the future.

“The big issue, in my opinion, is whether outside information came into the jury room and whether a judge can find that any ‘hypothetical juror’ would let it influence his decision,” she told News Outlet. “It’s definitely more complicated than that, but there is case law about it.”

Could the holdout sue Reddington?

“This is a strange new world in which disagreeing jurors and their surrogates conduct a public debate after the trial in the media and social media,” said Jack Lu, another retired Massachusetts judge.

Lindsay Clancy awaits jury deliberations

Lindsay Clancy looks at jurors as Judge Sullivan asks them to start deliberations for a sixth day during her murder trial on Thursday, Sept. 3, 2026, in Plymouth, Mass. (Pool Photo by Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger)

Reddington’s request for an inquiry into Desronvil is largely based on allegations from other jurors who accused him of having reasonable doubt about the case and ignoring it. He is seeking phone records, his confidential juror questionnaire and police records.

However, he’s also called him an “obstructionist” outside the courtroom and accused him of having an “agenda.”

“[The other jurors] know that they were robbed — by one man — for whatever his agenda was, who stole seven weeks of the life of these other jurors that were so attentive, so beautiful, so wonderful and listened to this evidence,” he told reporters after leaving the courthouse on Sept. 4, the day the mistrial was declared. 

Still, he downplayed speculation from legal analysts about a potential defamation lawsuit from the holdout against Clancy’s team.

Patrick Clancy on the stand

Patrick Clancy on the stand at Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial on July 29, 2026. (David L. Ryan/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

“Defamation law is textbook complex,” he told News Outlet. “Statements made in court proceedings are privileged.”

Statements made out of court that could appear to be “false statements of fact” may end up being considered opinions, he added.

“If a person says X happened, and we all know that person was not present, then it may be deemed to be an opinion,” he said. “This might apply to any alleged statements about what happened in the jury room.”

lindsay-clancy-ex-husband-patrick-clancy-new-wife-fox-news_005

Patrick Clancy and Rachel Danis hold hands as they walk through East Midtown in New York City, NY, Wedensday, September 2, 2026. (Elder Ordonez/InStar for News Outlet)

What’s next?

“I don’t think any of the legal maneuvering, double jeopardy, all that stuff, a hearing in the trial court with the juror, I don’t think it’s going anywhere,” said Mark Bederow, a New York-based criminal defense attorney and former prosecutor who is following the case.

“If you get down to brass tacks, once you get through all this, now you have to look at the DA and say, what are you doing?” he added.

Most prosecutors would not seek a second trial in a case where only one juror agreed with them, he said, but that appears unlikely in this case.

“At the first trial, the prosecution, in my view, failed miserably to satisfy their burden — but there is a credible argument that she’s guilty and intended to cause their deaths and knew right from wrong,” he said. “In order for them to win, they need to get better experts.”

The Commonwealth needs experts who can discredit Clancy’s defense experts, he said. And prosecutors also have room to improve their jury selection.

As for Reddington, he described him as “a titan of the Massachusetts bar” who is filing motions that make sense for his client’s benefit, regardless of his commentary outside the courtroom.

“That’s not frivolous, and any lawyer knows that,” he told News Outlet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Republicans fret Anthropic IPO will enrich far-left donors: '200 George Soroses'

Republicans Fear Anthropic IPO Could Create ‘200 George Soroses’ for Far-Left Donors

WASHINGTON — Republican insiders are raising concerns about the political influence that…
"No indication" recent outages are related to coordinated cyberattacks, officials say

Officials: No Sign Recent Outages Stem From Coordinated Cyberattacks

Washington — Senior U.S. national security officials told Congress on Wednesday that…
Judge Nathan Milliron issued public warning by Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct after viral IT worker video

Texas Judge Nathan Milliron Warned by Commission After Viral IT Video

A Texas judge who was captured in a viral courtroom outburst while…
Scientists warn of possible ‘ARkStorm,’ historic California flooding

Scientists Warn ARkStorm Could Trigger Historic California Flooding

California could be staring down a weather catastrophe of historic proportions, with…
Mamdani appoints lefty activists to NYC courts

Mamdani Appoints Left-Wing Activists to New York City Courts

New York City’s criminal and family courts are set for a significant…
San Diego votes to suspend 500 Flock license plate readers

San Diego City Council Suspends 500 Flock License Plate Readers

San Diego is shutting down roughly 500 automated license plate readers after…
Pope Leo breaks silence on rosary striking his face in Peru, reveals details about cancer: 'Major surgery'

Pope Leo Reveals Details of Major Cancer Surgery After Rosary Hits His Face in Peru

Pope Leo XIV broke his silence Monday after a rosary tossed by…
US infrastructure crumbles as adversaries power up – leaving Americans dangerously exposed: cyber expert

US Infrastructure Is Crumbling as Adversaries Build Cyber Power, Expert Warns

A series of technology breakdowns that grounded flights and interrupted workplace software…
California sheriff's deputy, special officer put on leave after 5-second conversation with ICE agents

California Deputy, Special Officer Put on Leave Over ICE Talk

Two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department have been placed on…
Video captures pit bull biting LAPD officer during Skid Row arrest

Video Captures Pit Bull Biting LAPD Officer During Skid Row Arrest

A police officer was bitten below the belt by a pit bull…
Long-lost Georgia O’Keeffe painting buried in NYC apartment closet for 40 years sells for $4.9M

Long-Lost O’Keeffe Painting Found in NYC Closet Sells for $4.9M

A Georgia O’Keeffe painting that spent nearly four decades hidden in a…
Iryna Zarutska's family files wrongful death lawsuit alleging no security guard was on train

Charlotte Seeks Dismissal of Iryna Zarutska Murder Lawsuit, Denies Responsibility

The city of Charlotte is urging a judge to dismiss a wrongful-death…