Lindsay Clancy juror who backed the defense also publicly cheered Karen Read's acquittal

Prosecutors seeking a second trial for Lindsay Clancy may confront the same challenge that led to the first trial ending without a verdict: persuading all 12 Massachusetts jurors to unanimously reject her insanity defense.

Jonathan Turley, a Fox News contributor and professor at The George Washington University Law School, said prosecutors must balance the risk of another deadlocked jury against the political and emotional consequences of dropping the case.

“The question is whether they could ever get a jury, particularly in Massachusetts, that would unanimously vote against this defendant,” Turley told News Outlet. “For prosecutors, they have to weigh that, but they may find the alternative equally unappealing — to simply walk away and say, ‘There are three dead children here, but we just don’t think we could ever win this case.’”

Lindsay Clancy

Defendant Lindsay Clancy watches jurors enter the courtroom during her murder trial on Friday, Sept. 4, 2026, in Plymouth, Mass. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)

Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor, said he believes the district attorney’s office should explore a plea deal. However, he acknowledged that an agreement appears unlikely given the nature of the crime and the defense’s position after jurors split 11-1, with only one juror supporting a murder conviction in the deaths of Clancy’s three young children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months.

“The reason I don’t think there’s any deal to be made here is Reddington has come out during his media tour and said that he’s not going to accept any deal that results in jail time,” he told News Outlet. “Even if you’re talking about first-degree or second-degree murder, in Massachusetts, first-degree, of course, has no possibility of parole. Second-degree has the possibility of a parole. That’s not something that Reddington and the defense are going to accept.”

Lindsay Clancy trial

Lindsay Clancy’s defense lawyer, Kevin J. Reddington, addresses the media outside of Plymouth Superior Court, Aug. 26, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

The defense does not dispute that Clancy, a 36-year-old former delivery room nurse, strangled her three children with exercise bands in January 2023 before attempting to take her own life.

She survived a fall from a second-story window but is now paralyzed.

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy. The three children were killed at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, has argued that mental illness or a mental defect made her not criminally responsible for the deaths.

In recent interviews, however, Reddington has said he is open to discussing a deal. He told Fox News’ Bryan Llenas last week that if prosecutors reduced the top charge to second-degree murder, he would waive a jury trial and ask a judge to hear the case, hoping Clancy would receive probation.

“I would like to see [Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz] reduce it to a second-degree so we could possibly waive a jury and try the case before a judge,” he said. “I would see Tim determine that the case should not go forward and dismiss it, or in the alternative fashion, something where Lindsay gets the mental, physical help that she needs rather than criminal prosecution — because I would not ever, ever in a million years have that woman go to Framingham State Prison.”

Lindsay Clancy trial

District Attorney Timothy Cruz leaves Plymouth Superior Court, Plymouth, Mass., Thursday, Sept. 3, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

As prosecutors consider whether to retry the case, Judge William Sullivan is shielding the identities of jurors from the mistrial. He ordered their names impounded indefinitely and their confidential questionnaires sealed for at least the next 10 days.

Lindsay Clancy in court for murder trial

Defendant Lindsay Clancy listens during her murder trial at Plymouth Superior Court in Plymouth, Mass., on July 30, 2026. (CJ Gunther/The Boston Herald via AP, Pool)

He cited threats and concerns for their safety.

Clancy, who is charged with murder in the strangling deaths of her three children, is due back in court on Sept. 29.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Alabama man Reuben Gulley acquitted in murder of TikTok star Ophelia Nichols' teen son

Alabama Man Reuben Gulley Acquitted in Murder of TikTok Star Ophelia Nichols’ Teen Son

An Alabama man who claimed self-defense for shooting TikTok star Ophelia Nichols’…
What autopsy results reveal about Fiona the hippo’s death

Fiona the Hippo’s Autopsy Reveals Cause of Death

An autopsy found that the knitted hat that killed Fiona the hippo…
Nearly 10,000 pounds of lead azide to be detonated at Iowa Army plant, causing lead dust plume into Illinois

Iowa Army Plant to Detonate 10,000 Pounds of Lead Azide, Sending Dust Toward Illinois

The U.S. Army has delayed the planned controlled detonation of nearly 10,000…
NYC ex-con arrested for good Samaritan's murder during dog fight

NYC Ex-Convict Arrested for Killing Good Samaritan During Dog Fight

A convicted ex-offender with at least 10 previous arrests has been charged…
Son of prominent California chef loses leg after suspected drunken driver plows into pedestrians

California Chef’s Son Loses Leg After Suspected Drunk Driver Hits Pedestrians

The son of a well-known California chef lost his leg after an…
Mayor Mamdani was detained at least twice by elite NYPD unit he’s controversially disbanding

Mayor Mamdani Was Detained at Least Twice by NYPD Unit He Disbanded

Mayor Zohran Mamdani was arrested and placed in zip ties at least…
California nonprofit CEO charged in multimillion-dollar fraud

California Nonprofit CEO Faces Multimillion-Dollar Fraud Charges

A wealthy California affordable-housing executive allegedly tried to escape prosecution aboard his…
American detained in Cuba for nearly a decade released

American Detained in Cuba for Nearly a Decade Is Released

A Cuban soldier waves the national flag during an “Anti-Imperialist” protest outside…
Judge rejects Alex Murdaugh's push to toss murder indictment over blood and ammo claims

Judge Rejects Alex Murdaugh Bid to Toss Murder Case Over Evidence

Murdaugh defense claims grand jury heard misleading testimony Alex Murdaugh appeared in…
Protesters call for regime change in Iran following deadly crash that killed 13 oil and gas workers

Iran Protests Demand Regime Change After Crash Kills 13 Oil and Gas Workers

Hundreds of people took to the streets of western Iran on Tuesday…
China could exploit US technology to threaten American forces, congressional watchdog leaders warn

Congressional Leaders Warn China Could Exploit US Tech Against Forces

China could use espionage, unauthorized access and other means to obtain advanced…
Israeli shepherds report suspected 'agricultural terror' targeting livestock

Israeli Shepherds Report Suspected ‘Agricultural Terror’ on Livestock

A string of suspected animal-poisoning attacks has alarmed Israeli security officials, farmers…