How long could the Lindsay Clancy jury remain deadlocked? Karen Read hung jury provides comparison.

Jurors in Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial informed the judge on Tuesday, and again on Wednesday, that they are deadlocked and unable to agree on a unanimous verdict. The development raises a familiar question in closely watched Massachusetts criminal cases: how long can deliberations continue when a jury says it cannot move forward?

After receiving the note, Judge William Sullivan instructed the panel to return to deliberations. Jurors continued working through the afternoon before leaving for the day at about 3:30 p.m. without reaching a verdict.

Hung jury in Karen Read and Emanuel Lopes trials

The phrase “deadlocked jury” has become increasingly familiar in Massachusetts courtrooms, particularly after several high-profile trials in recent years ended, or nearly ended, with hung juries. Among the most notable examples are the cases of Karen Read in 2024 and Emanuel Lopes in 2023 and 2024.

Lopes was accused in the 2018 killing of Weymouth Police Sgt. Michael Chesna. His first trial in 2023 ended in a mistrial after jurors could not reach a unanimous decision.

His second trial in 2024 also appeared headed for a stalemate. The jury told the judge three separate times that it was deadlocked. But after six days and 32 hours of deliberations, jurors ultimately returned a unanimous guilty verdict.

Karen Read’s first trial in 2024 followed a different path. In that case, the jury also reported being deadlocked, and after five days and 27 hours of deliberation, a mistrial was declared.

During Read’s trial, jurors first indicated they were at an impasse after 17.5 hours of deliberations, then reported the same problem again after 23.5 hours. Both times, they were ordered to keep deliberating. A mistrial was declared only after the jury told the court for a third time that it remained deadlocked.

Read was acquitted the following year after a second trial.

split-pic-template-83.jpg

Karen Read and Lindsay Clancy.

Nancy Lane/The Boston Herald and Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger

What is the “Tuey-Rodriguez” instruction?

In both of the above cases, the judge gave the jury what’s commonly known as a “dynamite” charge to encourage them to reach a verdict. That is also what happened Wednesday in Clancy’s trial. 

In Massachusetts, the dynamite charge is called a “Tuey-Rodriguez” instruction, named after a 1973 case.

The law permits judges to send deadlocked juries back to deliberate twice. More chances are allowed if jurors ask clarifying questions about the law.

Upon the second reporting of being “deadlocked,” judges will consult with the attorneys involved in the case, then will often read jurors the Tuey-Rodriguez charge, which says, in part:

“You should consider that it is desirable that the case be decided. You should consider that you have been selected in the same manner, and from the same source, as any future jury would be. There is no reason to suppose that the case will ever be submitted to [twelve] persons who are more intelligent, more impartial, or more competent to decide it than you are, or that more or clearer evidence will be produced on one side or the other. With all this in mind, it is your duty to decide this case if you can do so conscientiously.”

After this is read, if the jury returns deadlocked a third time, the judge then has the discretion to declare a mistrial.

If a mistrial is declared, the conditions for the defendant go back to what they were pretrial. In this case, that would mean Clancy would remain “in custody” at Tewksbury State Hospital under psychiatric care.

The Plymouth County district attorney, Timothy Cruz, would then get to decide whether to retry Clancy for first-degree murder — or for a lesser charge — or to not retry the case at all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Former Israeli ambassador to US lays out the three things Trump can do to speed up the ‘inevitable’ collapse of the Iranian regime 

Former Israeli Ambassador to US: 3 Things Trump Can Do to Speed Iran Regime Collapse

Ron Dermer, the former Israeli ambassador to the US, explained the three…
Washington man disembowled by hippo on honeymoon safari before wife saves him

Washington Man Survives Hippo Attack on Honeymoon as Wife Saves Him

Fellas, if she won’t punch a hippo in the face to save…
California sheriff's deputy, special officer put on leave after 5-second conversation with ICE agents

California Deputy, Special Officer Put on Leave Over ICE Talk

Two employees of the Orange County Sheriff’s Department have been placed on…
Kim Jong Un's daughter hits ski slopes in rare photos as North Korean dictator tours mountain resort

Kim Jong Un’s Daughter Skis in Rare Photos on North Korea Resort Tour

North Korean leader Kim Jong Un has been pictured relaxing in an…
Marin homeowner lifts Greenbrae house ahead of king tides

Marin Homeowner Raises Greenbrae House Ahead of King Tides

A Marin County physician is racing to raise his home before king…
US infrastructure crumbles as adversaries power up – leaving Americans dangerously exposed: cyber expert

US Infrastructure Is Crumbling as Adversaries Build Cyber Power, Expert Warns

A series of technology breakdowns that grounded flights and interrupted workplace software…
Man legally named Captain America charged with murder after allegedly giving victim’s girlfriend chilling note

Man Legally Named Captain America Charged With Murder After Note

Captain C. America, right, faces a first-degree murder charge in the death…
Mamdani appoints lefty activists to NYC courts

Mamdani Appoints Left-Wing Activists to New York City Courts

New York City’s criminal and family courts are set for a significant…
POWs, teens among 6 US soldiers from Korean War identified seven decades later

Six US Korean War Soldiers, Including POWs and Teens, Identified

Six US Army soldiers who disappeared during the Korean War—including two who…
Bumbling wannabe terrorist and banana king behind NYC plot to kill Trump learns his fate

Banana Tycoon Learns Fate in NYC Plot to Kill Donald Trump

A bumbling would-be terrorist and failed banana exporter who devised a poorly…
Major drug kingpin ‘The Kraken’ captured in California after yearslong hunt

Drug Kingpin ‘The Kraken’ Captured in California After Years-Long Hunt

Trump steps up fight against drug cartels in Ecuador Dana Perino examines…
‘World’s most wanted’ OnlyFans model desperately wants to leave US — after allegedly entering illegally, overstaying visa

‘World’s Most Wanted’ OnlyFans Model Seeks to Leave US

The Dutch OnlyFans creator who allegedly attempted to enter the US illegally…