High-end car hustle crashes as couple accused of flipping luxury rides with bogus titles

A couple from Florida is confronting numerous criminal charges related to an alleged scheme involving fraudulent vehicle titles at their luxury car dealership.

Michael Anthony Lucci, 32, and Emily Marie Lucci, 30, face allegations including nine counts each of making false statements in applications for bills of sale, possessing counterfeit vehicle titles or registrations, committing perjury through false written declarations, and uttering forged instruments. Additionally, they are charged with racketeering and organized fraud, as detailed in jail records reviewed by Fox News Digital.

The arrests followed an investigation by the Florida Highway Patrol (FHP) into their dealership, Luxury Auto Source, located in Davie. This inquiry began on January 21, as reported by NBC 6.

FHP’s interest in the couple’s business was piqued by allegations that they had provided fraudulent parts invoices to the department for a 2020 Nissan GT-R.

Emily Marie Lucci's Florida mugshot

According to Fox News Digital, Emily Marie Lucci, 30, is specifically charged with multiple counts related to false statements and counterfeit documentation, as noted in records from the Miami-Dade Corrections and Rehabilitation Department.

Documents filed by Emily Lucci at a Miami-Dade tag agency purportedly sought a certificate of title for the business, accompanied by a parts invoice alleging over $18,000 in repairs to significant vehicle components.

However, authorities allege the invoice was fake, with the real invoice totaling around $1,200, the outlet reported. Additionally, the vehicle had reportedly been listed for sale for $94,500 – a nearly $40,000 increase from its 2022 sale for $55,000. 

Following the alleged fraudulent invoice, FHP investigators began looking into additional vehicles listed for sale by the couple’s business.

Michael Anthony Lucci's Florida mugshot

Michael Anthony Lucci, 32, is charged with nine counts of making a false statement in an application for a bill of sale, nine counts of possessing counterfeit vehicle title or registration, nine counts of perjury by false written declaration, nine counts of uttering forged instruments, one count of racketeering and one count of organized fraud, according to jail records obtained by Fox News Digital.  (Miami-Dade Corrections and Rehabilitation Department)

Authorities ultimately found eight other luxury vehicles that had rebuilt Florida titles and fraudulent invoices, according to the outlet. 

The list of vehicles reportedly included a 2017 Bentley with a price of $63,900, a 2018 BMW M3 for sale for $37,900, a 2022 Porsche 911 with a price of $187,900, a 2020 Toyota Supra with a price of $36,900, a 2022 Dodge Charger SRT Hellcat for $52,900, and a 2023 Cadillac Escalade. 

The Dodge Charger allegedly possessed multiple VINs and the motor was traced back to a vehicle stolen out of North Carolina, the outlet reported.

Luxury vehicles in a dealership lot

The married couple allegedly falsified vehicle titles from their self-owned car dealership, Luxury Auto Source, in Davie, Florida. (iStock)

“At the conclusion of my review, I identified nine vehicles currently offered for sale by Luxury Auto Source LLC that were titled through the submission of fraudulent or manipulated parts invoices to DHSMV,” an investigator reportedly wrote in the arrest reports. 

“These vehicles constitute contraband, as their titles were obtained through fraudulent means. These vehicles, and potentially additional vehicles sold through this dealership, present a significant risk to innocent purchasers, who may unknowingly buy vehicles subject to seizure and forfeiture, resulting in both the loss of the vehicle and associated funds due to their status as contraband.”

Michael Lucci was reportedly taken into custody as FHP officers executed a search warrant at the business, with Emily Lucci later turning herself in to authorities. 

The pair were released after both were granted $30,000 bonds, according to jail records obtained by Fox News Digital.

Fox News Digital was unable to immediately locate an attorney representing both Emily and Michael Lucci. FHP did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment. 

You May Also Like
Chicago shootings this weekend: At least 10 shot, 2 fatally, in gun violence across city, police department says

Arlington Heights Police Search for Suspect in Teen Sexual Assault at Eastman Parking Garage

ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, Ill. (WLS) — Police in north suburban Arlington Heights are…
Experts debunk Tyler Robinson's ballistics claim: 'Unable to identify is not the same as ruled out'

Prosecutors Grant Limited Immunity to Roommate and Lover of Alleged Charlie Kirk Assassin Tyler Robinson

Robinson defense alleging prosecutor misconduct Criminal defense lawyer Josh Ritter appeared on…
Coast Guard opens fire on boat smuggling 25 Chinese nationals near Florida after it refused to stop

US Coast Guard Fires on Smuggling Boat Carrying 25 Chinese Migrants Off Florida After Pursuit

The U.S. Coast Guard fired on a boat off the Florida coast…
Barry Moore Wins Runoff for Tuberville's Senate Seat, Despite a 'Dewey Defeats Truman' Snafu

Barry Moore Secures Tuberville’s Senate Seat in Runoff, Despite Election-Night Reporting Mix-Up

Alabama Republicans headed into a runoff for the U.S. Senate between Rep.…
US Secret Service prepares to secure Jackson Park, Chicago Obama Center Opening Ceremony

US Secret Service Finalizes Security Plan for Chicago’s Jackson Park Ahead of Obama Center Opening Ceremony

CHICAGO (WLS) — The U.S. Secret Service says it has spent the…
Senior US officials dictate memorandum with Iran to journalists+

US Officials Quietly Shape Iran Memorandum Through Journalist Briefings

Senior U.S. officials on Wednesday briefed reporters on the memorandum of understanding…
Couple recalls narrow escape from Merrillville, Indiana tornado as severe weather tomorrow includes tornado risk, strong storms

Couple Recalls Close Call in Merrillville Tornado as Tomorrow’s Severe Weather Brings New Tornado Threat

MERRILLVILLE, Ind. (WLS) — A week after a tornado ripped through Merrillville,…
Pence: Trump's Iran Deal 'Smacks of Appeasement'

Pence Says Trump’s Iran Deal Approach ‘Smacks of Appeasement’

Former Vice President Mike Pence sharply criticized President Donald Trump’s emerging deal…
G7 leaders back Trump's plan to end Iran war that faces skepticism at home

G7 Leaders Endorse Trump’s Iran War Exit Plan Amid Skepticism at Home

EVIAN-LES-BAINS, France — Leaders at the Group of Seven summit on Wednesday…
Air Force identifies 8 crew members killed in B-52 Stratofortress crash at Edwards Air Force Base

Air Force Identifies Eight Service Members Killed in B-52 Stratofortress Crash at Edwards Air Force Base

Officials on Wednesday released the names of the eight people killed in…
A mother's concern, call to authorities may have prevented potential attack on UFC event at the White House

Mother’s Tip to Authorities May Have Stopped Potential Attack at White House UFC Event

A suspected plan to attack Sunday night’s UFC event at the White…
Texas plane crash leaves one dead, more injured after business jet catches fire on highway

Texas Highway Plane Crash: 1 Dead, Several Injured After Business Jet Bursts Into Flames

A business jet went down on a Texas highway Tuesday night and…