North Carolina furniture manufacturer allegedly kills business partner hours after losing contract dispute

A North Carolina furniture manufacturer is accused of fatally shooting his business partner this week, just hours after a judge ruled against him in a contract dispute.

Willard Gary Black, 85, has been charged with second-degree murder in the Wednesday killing of Robert Roger Arguelles, according to Queen City News. Authorities said Arguelles was shot in the chest and back.

The shooting took place at Old Hickory Tannery, the company the two men co-owned.

Court records show Black had been ordered earlier that day to pay Arguelles $310,882.74 in connection with a business disagreement, Court TV reported.

Black and Arguelles had been tied together in business for years. In 2018, Black sold Arguelles a 49.9% stake in the company. But Arguelles later alleged that he had loaned Black $280,000 and that only $23,876.19 of that amount had been repaid, according to the report.

Black is being held in connection with the case as the investigation continues.

Both men reached an agreement to settle the lawsuit for $310,882.74, but after filing the paperwork with the court, Black sought to withdraw his consent.

On Wednesday, a judge denied his request and ordered Black to pay Arguelles, 59, the amount of the original agreement.

Judge gavel resting on a wooden block with scales of justice and law books in the background

A judge’s gavel rests on a wooden block with scales of justice and law books in a courtroom setting. (Brian A. Jackson/South Florida Sun Sentinel)

Hours later, both men got into an argument at the business, which led to the shooting, authorities said. Police officers arrived and attempted to save Arguelles, who died at the scene.

Arguelles had served as an Alexander County Schools board member since 2022.

In a statement, District Superintendent Bill Griffin described Arguelles as an “amazing father, husband, and board member who has faithfully supported our school system for almost four years.”

“In honor of his memory, our district fully supports and respects the family’s privacy as they navigate this profound loss,” he added.

–>

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *