Farmer who shot and killed teenage burglar will not face any charges

A farmer who fatally shot a teenager accused of breaking into his home will not be prosecuted, officials have confirmed.

Rob Lomas, 52, was detained on suspicion of murder after 19-year-old Marcus Smith was discovered dead at the Peak District property in May 2024.

Officers were called at about 1.20am following reports of a burglary at the farm, which sits on a secluded rural lane in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire.

At the scene, police found Mr Smith fatally injured inside the property, while a second man was located in the road outside with serious injuries.

The wounded man was taken to hospital for treatment before being arrested on suspicion of aggravated burglary.

A third person was later arrested on suspicion of the same offence after police stopped a vehicle on the A6 near Chapel-en-le-Frith several hours afterwards.

It subsequently emerged that police had also been called to the farm the previous day following reports of a separate break-in.

In a statement released on Tuesday, the Crown Prosecution Service said it had concluded that Mr Lomas should not face charges over the death of “one intruder” and the serious injury of another on his property.

Rob Lomas (pictured) was being questioned on suspicion of murder after Marcus Smith, 19, was found dead at the his property at Mosley Hall Farm

Rob Lomas (pictured) was being questioned on suspicion of murder after Marcus Smith, 19, was found dead at the his property at Mosley Hall Farm

Marcus Smith was found dead after police called to reports of a break-in at a the farm on a remote country lane, in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire

Marcus Smith was found dead after police called to reports of a break-in at a the farm on a remote country lane, in Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire

Derbyshire police had been called to reports of a burglary at the remote Peak District farmhouse the day earlier and then a second raid at 1.20am the next day

Derbyshire police had been called to reports of a burglary at the remote Peak District farmhouse the day earlier and then a second raid at 1.20am the next day

Police wearing purple gloves comb the farm outbuildings for evidence at the remote Peak District farmhouse

Police wearing purple gloves comb the farm outbuildings for evidence at the remote Peak District farmhouse

 It said the decision related to an incident at a ‘remote premises near Whaley Bridge, Derbyshire, where a householder discharged a legally held firearm when confronted with burglars in his home’.

Janine McKinney, Chief Crown Prosecutor for CPS East Midlands, said: ‘After careful analysis of all the evidence gathered during the police investigation, our prosecutors have decided that there will be no criminal charges in relation to the death of Marcus Smith or the serious injury of another male.

‘This decision has been made in accordance with our statutory legal tests as prosecutors and the law surrounding the householder’s rights to defend themself.

‘Our thoughts are with Mr Smith’s family and loved ones.’ 

Three men will face proceedings for burglary in relation to the incident and a burglary at the same property the night before, the statement said. 

The law allows individuals to use reasonable force to defend themselves, others and their property if threatened with violence. 

Following his arrest, Mr Lomas’s son Joshua set up a fundraiser using the hashtag ‘freethefarmer’.

He wrote: ‘We are raising much needed funds to support our family and my father, Rob, through this very difficult time.

‘Rob has the most steadfast loyalty you could ever wish for in a father and friend and has always been there for me, and all of his many friends.

‘As every farmer does, he works relentlessly in all weathers, but always makes time for a brew and a friendly humorous chat.

‘During the early hours of the 1st May, Rob encountered intruders inside his property, having had a burglary the night prior also. Further details are available online and I won’t duplicate.

‘Rob, Kate (his partner) and I now need help in the coming weeks. That’s why we need your kind and extremely valuable help.’

Mr Smith was a former pupil at Chapel-en-le-Frith High School and a footballer who had played for local club Chapel Town FC. 

Tributes were paid online after his death with friends describing him as the ‘loveliest boy’ and ‘sweet and polite’, and someone who ‘lit up every room he entered’.

The case echoes that of Tony Martin, the farmer who shot dead a teenage intruder at his isolated Norfolk home in 1999. 

Martin was jailed in 2000 for the murder of Fred Barras, 16, and for injuring 29-year-old Brendon Fearon in the same incident. 

He was released three years later after the conviction was reduced to manslaughter.

The shooting at Martin’s farmhouse in Emneth Hungate, known as Bleak House, caused a national debate over homeowners’ rights.

Mr Martin died last year at the age of 80.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

British Swimmer Lewis Pugh Swims Hormuz to Spotlight Wildlife

British endurance swimmer Lewis Pugh has taken on icy waters in both…

COP31 Nears Collapse After EU Rejects UN Climate Deal

UN climate negotiations have descended into crisis after the European Union rejected…

Strictly’s Kai Reunites With Delta Goodrem for Highest Score

Strictly Come Dancing professional Kai Widdrington declared that it was “good to…

Nations Extend UN Talks on Lethal Autonomous Weapons for Two More Years

International efforts to establish firm limits on AI-controlled killer robots and drones…

NBA Icon Blasts Baltimore Ravens Star Over ‘Criminals’ Remark

Baltimore native and NBA Hall of Famer Carmelo Anthony has taken aim…

Violent Fare-Dodger Laughed After Assault on Bloodied Police Officer

A fare evader punched a police officer in the face, leaving him…

Theresa May Tells Andy Burnham to ‘Move On’ After Brexit Vote

Theresa May has told Andy Burnham to accept Brexit and “move on”,…

Private school pupil numbers fall at two-thirds since VAT change

Pupil numbers have fallen at around two-thirds of independent schools since Labour…

Pregnant Woman Thought Heartburn Was Normal—It Was Deadly Colon Cancer

When Geraldine Levano developed severe acid reflux, she assumed it was simply…

Thomas Markle’s Asia Trips to Meet Girls Were ‘Open Secret’

Thomas Markle’s alleged “girls’ trips to Asia” were an “open family secret”,…

Trump Appoints Hegseth Loyalist as National Cyber Director

President Donald Trump has selected Kirsten Davies, a former cosmetics-industry technology executive,…

Book Claims Prince William Plans to Strip Prince Harry of Titles When He Becomes King

Prince William is preparing a sweeping overhaul of the monarchy that could…